diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index 77b0f4b..24f1701 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -30,9 +30,11 @@ The project asks whether independently reconstructed quantum-chemical evidence s All fourteen propositions received determinate classifications: - **13 consistent** with the corresponding monograph propositions; -- **1 partially consistent**: P12 retains a cross-estimand onset boundary; +- **1 partially consistent**: P12 retains its published classification while the basis for that label is reviewed; - **0 globally inconsistent and 0 unknown**. +**P12 interpretation correction:** “Partially consistent” does **not** mean that one P12 subclaim has been independently verified as correct and another as incorrect. The monograph's six-point CESE ledger has been checked arithmetically, but the independent candidate CESE recalculation and source-method alignment do not yet cover the complete six-point, same-estimand test. The separate ASE trend uses a different estimand: its onset cannot directly contradict the CESE onset. The published label is retained pending formal review of its evidentiary basis; this correction neither changes the frozen results nor automatically upgrades P12 to “consistent.” + “Consistent” is a proposition-level verdict: evidence produced under the registered protocol supports the corresponding monograph proposition. Scope, evidence identity, and independence are reported separately; a proposition-level result is not automatically generalized into a universal law. Representative frozen results are: diff --git a/README_zh-CN.md b/README_zh-CN.md index aeb12a8..f150a43 100644 --- a/README_zh-CN.md +++ b/README_zh-CN.md @@ -30,9 +30,11 @@ AI4OrgChem是一个面向有机结构基础理论独立计算重构与证据评 十四项命题均形成确定性分类: - **13项一致**; -- **1项部分一致**:P12保留不同估计量下起始尺寸不可直接比较的边界; +- **1项部分一致**:P12暂沿用已发布分类,其分类依据仍需复核; - **整体不一致0项,未知0项**。 +**P12解释勘误:**“部分一致”**不表示**已独立证实P12的某个子项正确、另一个子项错误。原著六点CESE源账本已经算术核验,但独立候选CESE复算及原著方法条件对齐尚未覆盖完整六点的同估计量检验。另一支路的ASE与CESE不是同一估计量,ASE起始尺寸不能直接反证CESE起始尺寸。已发布标签暂予保留,待正式复核分类依据;本次勘误既不改动冻结结果,也不自动把P12升级为“一致”。 + “一致”是命题级判定,表示按照登记协议获得的证据支持相应原著命题。适用范围、证据身份和独立性另行列示;单项结果不自动外推为普遍定律。 代表性冻结结果如下: diff --git a/manifests/sha256-manifest.json b/manifests/sha256-manifest.json index 95413cf..863c1e1 100644 --- a/manifests/sha256-manifest.json +++ b/manifests/sha256-manifest.json @@ -954,14 +954,14 @@ { "path": "README.md", "artifact_role": "repository-root", - "bytes": 23700, - "sha256": "4fc35159d35c2fa78636e8c37c3b3a913ab8e0b111c7f268ebc71dcc0f46f090" + "bytes": 24407, + "sha256": "df16e1a8ba71b78d9285df8f31911c09437a80144654767047980e52cc250d7a" }, { "path": "README_zh-CN.md", "artifact_role": "repository-root", - "bytes": 10096, - "sha256": "410b441037c67283cafa4b170a774ff0437ce620d3143087a6710727d17689bb" + "bytes": 10596, + "sha256": "88da5e95b3e596b06b24aeb155d9c0184129d0319a7b282b56aa1a04816828c3" }, { "path": "RELEASE_NOTES_v0.3.1.md",