[REVIEW] ir-playbook: add tabletop inject decision capture gates
Skill Being Reviewed
Skill name: ir-playbook
Skill path: skills/incident-response/ir-playbook/
False Positive Analysis
A tabletop exercise can be successful despite imperfect response if decision points, owners, assumptions, and follow-up actions are captured.
Coverage Gaps
The playbook should capture tabletop inject decisions, not only agenda and lessons learned. Without decision logs, teams cannot prove why they notified, contained, escalated, or deferred.
Edge Cases
- Inject arrives after simulated business-hours cutoff.
- Legal/comms decision differs by region.
- Participant substitutes for actual decision owner.
Remediation Quality
- Add inject log: time, inject, options, decision owner, decision, rationale, and follow-up.
- Require evidence of unresolved decision gaps.
- Link exercise findings to playbook updates.
Comparison to Other Tools
Exercise platforms record timelines; IR playbook review must verify decision traceability.
Overall Assessment
Add tabletop decision gates so exercises improve real response governance.
Bounty Info
[REVIEW] ir-playbook: add tabletop inject decision capture gates
Skill Being Reviewed
Skill name:
ir-playbookSkill path:
skills/incident-response/ir-playbook/False Positive Analysis
A tabletop exercise can be successful despite imperfect response if decision points, owners, assumptions, and follow-up actions are captured.
Coverage Gaps
The playbook should capture tabletop inject decisions, not only agenda and lessons learned. Without decision logs, teams cannot prove why they notified, contained, escalated, or deferred.
Edge Cases
Remediation Quality
Comparison to Other Tools
Exercise platforms record timelines; IR playbook review must verify decision traceability.
Overall Assessment
Add tabletop decision gates so exercises improve real response governance.
Bounty Info
CONTRIBUTING.mdbounty terms.samik4184@gmail.com