diff --git a/code-review b/code-review new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0cf68b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/code-review @@ -0,0 +1,51 @@ +## Code Review for TestProcessing-1 +This review is for the code in Program.cs of the TestProcessing-1 project. The program reads a text file (sample.txt), removes punctuation, converts all words to lowercase, counts the number of times each word appears, and shows how many unique words there are. + +1. Is the code properly documented/commented? +There are no comments in the code, which makes it harder to understand what each part is doing. +Suggestions: +- Add a summary at the beginning of the Main method to explain what the program does. +- Add short comments above important steps like reading the file, processing lines, and counting words. +- Use clear variable names (e.g., instead of a, use wordCounts). + +2. Does the code handle errors properly? +The code does not check for errors like missing files or invalid user input. +Suggestions: +- Use try-catch blocks when opening files to avoid crashes. +- Check if the input path is empty before trying to open it. +- Confirm that the file exists before processing. + +3. Suggestions to improve the code: +Naming: +- Variables like a, z, and w are confusing. +- Use clear names like wordCounts, filePath, and lines. + +Code Structure: +- All code is inside Main, which makes it hard to read. +- Break it into smaller methods: ReadFile(), CountWords(), etc. + +Error Handling: +- No handling for missing files or bad input. +- Add try-catch and input checks. + +File Assumptions: +- Code assumes the file always exists and is correct. +- You can set a default file or show a clear message if it's missing. + +OOP Principles: +- This code is procedural. +- Try creating a class like WordCounter to group related logic and make the code reusable. + +Output: +- The prompt gimmefile is not clear. +- Use something like: "Please enter the file path:" +- Also, align the output better and fix typos like uniquez. + +Program Logic: +- The logic works, but some parts can be cleaner. +- Use built-in functions like RemoveEmptyEntries etc. + + + + +