Interceptors not running

[will093]

I have imported HttpModule and HttpInterceptorModule, and created an interceptor service:

import { Injectable } from '@angular/core';
import { Http } from '@angular/http';
import { HttpInterceptorService } from 'ng-http-interceptor';

@Injectable()
export class HttpErrorResponseInterceptor {

  constructor(private http: Http, private httpInterceptor: HttpInterceptorService) { }

  initialise() {

    this.httpInterceptor.request().addInterceptor((data, method) => {
      console.log(method, data);
      return data;
    });

    this.httpInterceptor.response().addInterceptor((res, method) => {
      return res.do(r => console.log(method, r));
    });

    this.http.get('/')
      .subscribe(console.log);
  }
}

initialise() is then called in the top level AppComponent.

When I debug in Chrome/IE/Firefox I can see http.get is called - but the interceptors never run, and there are no errors. I have tried injecting InterceptableHttp instead of Http, and the interceptors still don't run.

I am using Angular 4, specifically, the versions I am using are:

"@angular/http": "^4.3.1",
"ng-http-interceptor": "^3.1.2",

[gund]

What is the order of imports of HttpModule and HttpInterceptorModulev in your module?

Because if you have HttpModule after HttpInterceptorModule it will override proxied Http service with original one.

[will093]

@gund The problem still occurs if I import HttpModule first. I was wondering if something like that was occurring, but then I would think InterceptableHttp should still work, which it doesn't.

[gund]

Yeah you are right, InterceptableHttp should have been worked any way...
It's weird why requests are not intercepted, can you please make a plunkr with this issue reproduced?

[davorpeic]

I have the same setup as you, and I was using HttpInterceptorModule.noOverrideHttp() and I didn't get any logs, I switched to normal module HttpInterceptorModule and now I can see all requests. (Ionic 3 app).

[will093]

I have identified the cause of the issue. Another plugin I am using in my project seems to provide its own HTTP implementation via a factory:

https://github.com/aitboudad/ng-loading-bar

As each plugin provides its own implementation of HTTP I think the 2 plugins are incompatible.

[gund]

Yeah, only the last Http provided will be used. But you should be able to still use InterceptableHttp to make interceptable requests.

[Yugloocamai]

I really need to be able to intercept ALL Http requests. Everything throughout my entire app lifecycle, including all DI.

[gund]

This is a really interesting case when you really want to compose your DI providers but not completely override them.

So far I don't know any solution of how to achieve this but it definitely makes sense in such scenarios.

Maybe we should open an issue in official Angular repo and discuss this problem/feature...

What do you guys think?