Skip to content

Substation frequencies showing NaN when there are multiple values #988

@TranslatorPS

Description

@TranslatorPS

When tagging AC/DC traction substations, I do frequency=50;0, which when matched with for example voltage=15000;3000 should indicate that 15kV is at 50Hz AC, while 3kV is DC.

With the newest frequency import as per #982, such dual frequency values throw a "NaN Hz, NaN Hz":
Image
Any substation in Kraków, Poland will show this.

I would ask to look into displaying both frequencies. I think it far more appropriate to tag both frequencies, as leaving just frequency=50 would falsely indicate that the secondary (traction) voltage is also at 50Hz AC, which is as far from truth as you can get in such cases. (Well, technically the transformers are actually AC-to-AC and only then is there a rectifier unit involved of course, so there is 3kV AC involved, but it's never output anywhere.)
If it helps, I also try to adamantly tag such substations with frequency_conversion=ac_dc.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions