-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 212
Open
Description
First and foremost, I want to express my gratitude for the hard work and effort you've invested in creating SSH-MITM. It's an invaluable resource for the community.
However, I've noticed a few concerning issues and would like to outline them for clarity:
- Outdated Software: SSH-MITM and its corresponding Docker container positronsecurity/ssh-mitm have been stagnant for about two years without updates.
- Known Vulnerabilities: SSH-Audit, another tool from you, has highlighted that SSH-MITM currently contains 11 documented vulnerabilities. These have been addressed in OpenSSH, but remain unpatched in SSH-MITM. The detailed list of these vulnerabilities can be found here.
- Docker Container Vulnerabilities: The Docker container for SSH-MITM, based on Ubuntu 20.04, poses potential threats due to its known vulnerabilities, as documented here. The exact relevance of these to SSH-MITM isn't confirmed, but it's a potential threat.
- Responsibility to Users: As security professionals, we bear a responsibility to ensure the tools we provide are safe and reliable. If there are constraints preventing active maintenance, users should be clearly and prominently informed.
- Reference by SSH.com: Your tool is still being referenced by SSH.com, which may inadvertently give users a false sense of security.
Suggested Actions:
- Address the 11 vulnerabilities in SSH-MITM and update the Docker container to a more secure and recent base.
- Add a clear and prominent warning at the start of the README about the tool's status and associated risks, especially if active maintenance isn't feasible.
- Consider archiving the project on GitHub if there are no plans for future updates. This provides a clear indicator to users that the tool is no longer in active development.
Thank you for your dedication to the security community. I hope this feedback is seen in the constructive spirit it's intended.
s23hck
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels