I am not able to output all my VM's Ygg addresses after the change of the argument ygg_ip to planetary_ip

[s-areal]

I have multiple VM running for months now.

I realized some random ygg ip addresses are lacking on terraform output:

ygg_ip_1410 = ""
ygg_ip_1413 = ""
ygg_ip_1458 = "302:f959:4b26:b3dc:f5bb:9fc3:7bef:b2fc"
ygg_ip_1554 = ""
ygg_ip_1591 = ""
ygg_ip_1598 = "300:1d67:64f1:941b:6b49:4c14:60e9:49ea"
ygg_ip_1609 = ""
ygg_ip_1675 = "301:8b73:6e74:709d:20b8:1940:ca8b:d218"

This never, ever happened before.

how can I output now, after ygg_ip changed to planetary_ip all the addresses of the VMs I am running?

I've tried changing the ygg_ip to planetary_ip on main.tf but i got this error message:

Error: Unsupported attribute
│
│ on main.tf line 2290, in output "Planetary_ip_1394":
│ 2290: value = grid_deployment._1394.vms[0].planetary_ip
│
│ This object has no argument, nested block, or exported attribute named "planetary_ip".

[scottyeager]

Also I think it's worth asking, why change ygg_ip to planetary_ip in the first place? If we continue with a notion of "planetary network", it would probably not involve Yggdrasil since we are now developing Mycelium as a replacement.

[xmonader]

Also I think it's worth asking, why change ygg_ip to planetary_ip in the first place? If we continue with a notion of "planetary network", it would probably not involve Yggdrasil since we are now developing Mycelium as a replacement.

Mycelium is developed along with yggdrasil and the plan is still to support both

[scottyeager]

Mycelium is developed along with yggdrasil and the plan is still to support both

I know we're not planning to drop support for Yggdrasil. I'm just saying that with Mycelium in play it no longer makes sense to give a special name to Yggdrasil in the context of the ThreeFold network. Calling it "Planetary Network" has always been a source of confusion anyway. Changing it here will only cause more confusion, and force people to update their main.tf files. So what's the upside?

[mik-tf]

Mycelium is developed along with yggdrasil and the plan is still to support both

I agree it's important to keep the support of both.

The project mycelium states clearly in the book that it's the "planetary network":

So I guess to the minimum planetary should now be addressed for mycelium and yggdrasil should be yggdrasil and nothing more

• planetary_ip for mycelium
• yggdrasil_ip for yggdrasil

That being said, I do agree with Scott that

• mycelium_ip
• yggdrasil_ip

is the simplest and clearest.

IMO, if the nomenclature is already established in the community, docs and recent codes, we should revert to ygg_ip, and add myc_ip if needed for mycelium. This will be a smooth addition and not a change to properly working nomenclature, while being natural to users.

• ygg_ip
• myc_ip

Proposition

So I propose this, we don't use planetary as it's misleading. We go with this:

• mycelium_ip and myc_ip
• yggdrasil_ip and ygg_ip

[mik-tf]

@xmonader does the following make sense to you?

• mycelium_ip and myc_ip
• yggdrasil_ip and ygg_ip

It'd be way easier to understand.