01a077f5 - Coordinate assigned issues through static scripts - #74
Conversation
JonnyLuca
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Grok logic — rejected at 40d80d6
src/agent_cli/coordinator_github.py:1391: A stale question checkpoint plus a later authorized reply can default back to implement after closed-unmerged or nonhuman-merge outcomes; require an eligible explicit resume phase and clear or ignore stale checkpoints for non-recoverable states.
JonnyLuca
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Grok quality — rejected at 40d80d6
src/agent_cli/coordinator_github.py:436: Hard CI inventory shape or truncation faults keep phase=ci instead of entering the recoverable blocked/checkpoint path; distinguish protocol faults from transient transport and pending states.
src/agent_cli/coordinator_github.py:914: An unverified formal approval publication invalidates the durable attempt even on transient transport failure; preserve and reconcile that attempt unless actual revocation is observed.
JonnyLuca
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Grok logic — rejected at ac5509a
src/agent_cli/coordinator_github.py:628: Fresh CI pending or transport failures during readiness, formal approval and leave-draft become a human reply gate through advance_one; preserve script-owned observation and retry without premature readiness.
src/agent_cli/coordinator_github.py:432: The phase_ci PR-view transport runs outside the transient inventory handling and still requires a human reply on a temporary fetch failure; apply the same hard-versus-transient classification to both CI sources.
marassteiner
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Formal approval for 6bac9cedfb892996e44906cea785e4c7898adbd5, submitted by the static executor through the explicitly selected separate review account.
Evidence verified before submission:
- Four independent complete approvals on this exact head: Grok quality and logic, followed by Codex quality and logic; zero introduced findings.
- Full static-script tests passed on the clean signed head.
- Current-head GitHub workflow inventory and PR check rollup are green; PR is mergeable.
This publishes the recorded independent review results. It is not an additional model review and does not merge the PR. A human merges.
|
Ready for review evidence for
This is Ready for review, not merged or completed; merge remains with a human. |
EN:
Adds an optional static coordinator that accepts assigned GitHub issues and drives implementation, checks, reviews and pull-request readiness through explicitly configured accounts and roles. The script owns GitHub communication, process launches and monitoring; models return bounded work results. Installation remains unconfigured by default, and completion requires a verified human merge.
DE:
Ergänzt einen optionalen statischen Koordinator, der zugewiesene GitHub-Issues übernimmt und Umsetzung, Prüfungen, Reviews und PR-Bereitschaft über ausdrücklich konfigurierte Accounts und Rollen steuert. Das Script übernimmt GitHub-Kommunikation, Prozessstarts und Überwachung; die KI liefert begrenzte Arbeitsergebnisse zurück. Die Installation bleibt standardmäßig unkonfiguriert und der Abschluss erfordert einen nachgewiesenen menschlichen Merge.
Implementation and limits
Validated Ready evidence
Validated head:
6bac9cedfb892996e44906cea785e4c7898adbd5.Static-script full tests:
1617 passed, 3 skipped, 47 subtests passed in 120.16s (0:02:00).Independent complete Grok inner review approved, followed by four independent PR review approvals: Grok quality and logic, then Codex quality and logic.
GitHub workflow inventory and check rollup are green on this head. The script verified the clean worktree, signature and formal approval by
marassteiner.Ready for review is not merged or completed; a human merges.