Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull request overview
Updates the sg-hdb-bto-announcements skill/prompt verification guidance to address Deferred Income Assessment (DIA) scenarios for housing grant assessment timing.
Changes:
- Add a verification rule describing when the grant is assessed for Deferred Income Assessment cases.
- Mirror the same rule in both the native skill spec and the universal prompt version.
Reviewed changes
Copilot reviewed 2 out of 2 changed files in this pull request and generated 2 comments.
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| skills/public/sg-hdb-bto-announcements/SKILL.md | Adds a DIA-specific verification rule for grant assessment timing. |
| ports/universal/sg-hdb-bto-announcements-prompt.md | Mirrors the DIA-specific verification rule in the universal prompt. |
💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.
| Verification rules: | ||
| - For launch details, prioritize official pages with publication dates. | ||
| - For eligibility or grants, link to official pages and avoid uncited rules. | ||
| - For Deferred Income Assessment cases, state that the grant is assessed during the deferred income assessment near key collection (not at key collection). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This instruction is internally inconsistent/unclear: it says the grant is assessed "near key collection" but also "not at key collection". Consider rephrasing to a single unambiguous timing (e.g., before/at/after key collection) and avoid the parenthetical contradiction.
Also, "the grant" is ambiguous in this spec—if you mean Enhanced Housing Grant (EHG) or a specific grant type, name it explicitly to prevent incorrect assistant outputs.
| - For Deferred Income Assessment cases, state that the grant is assessed during the deferred income assessment near key collection (not at key collection). | |
| - For Deferred Income Assessment cases, state that the Enhanced CPF Housing Grant (EHG) is assessed during the Deferred Income Assessment, which typically occurs shortly before key collection. |
| Verification rules: | ||
| - For launch details, prioritize official pages with publication dates. | ||
| - For eligibility or grants, link to official pages and avoid uncited rules. | ||
| - For Deferred Income Assessment cases, state that the grant is assessed during the deferred income assessment near key collection (not at key collection). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This instruction is internally inconsistent/unclear: it says the grant is assessed "near key collection" but also "not at key collection". Consider rephrasing to a single unambiguous timing (e.g., before/at/after key collection) and avoid the parenthetical contradiction.
Also, "the grant" is ambiguous in this prompt—if you mean Enhanced Housing Grant (EHG) or a specific grant type, name it explicitly to prevent incorrect assistant outputs.
| - For Deferred Income Assessment cases, state that the grant is assessed during the deferred income assessment near key collection (not at key collection). | |
| - For Deferred Income Assessment cases, state that the Enhanced CPF Housing Grant (EHG) is assessed during the Deferred Income Assessment before key collection. |
|
Thanks for the update on Deferred Income Assessment. Could you refine this line for clarity before merge? Current wording is a bit ambiguous: “near key collection” vs “not at key collection” For Deferred Income Assessment cases, state explicitly that the Enhanced CPF Housing Grant (EHG) is assessed during the Deferred Income Assessment stage, which is typically shortly before key collection. |
No description provided.