Skip to content
Open
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
51 changes: 51 additions & 0 deletions code-review
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,51 @@
## Code Review for TestProcessing-1
This review is for the code in Program.cs of the TestProcessing-1 project. The program reads a text file (sample.txt), removes punctuation, converts all words to lowercase, counts the number of times each word appears, and shows how many unique words there are.

1. Is the code properly documented/commented?
There are no comments in the code, which makes it harder to understand what each part is doing.
Suggestions:
- Add a summary at the beginning of the Main method to explain what the program does.
- Add short comments above important steps like reading the file, processing lines, and counting words.
- Use clear variable names (e.g., instead of a, use wordCounts).

2. Does the code handle errors properly?
The code does not check for errors like missing files or invalid user input.
Suggestions:
- Use try-catch blocks when opening files to avoid crashes.
- Check if the input path is empty before trying to open it.
- Confirm that the file exists before processing.

3. Suggestions to improve the code:
Naming:
- Variables like a, z, and w are confusing.
- Use clear names like wordCounts, filePath, and lines.

Code Structure:
- All code is inside Main, which makes it hard to read.
- Break it into smaller methods: ReadFile(), CountWords(), etc.

Error Handling:
- No handling for missing files or bad input.
- Add try-catch and input checks.

File Assumptions:
- Code assumes the file always exists and is correct.
- You can set a default file or show a clear message if it's missing.

OOP Principles:
- This code is procedural.
- Try creating a class like WordCounter to group related logic and make the code reusable.

Output:
- The prompt gimmefile is not clear.
- Use something like: "Please enter the file path:"
- Also, align the output better and fix typos like uniquez.

Program Logic:
- The logic works, but some parts can be cleaner.
- Use built-in functions like RemoveEmptyEntries etc.