Scientific Value
Parametric approximations break down with n<10 or sparse features. Exact tests provide valid inference.
Scope (Deferred)
- Fisher exact, exact NB (edgeR), permutation PERMANOVA
- Methods: exact_fisher, exact_nb, permutation
Difficulty: Hard
Risks: Performance 10-100x slower, memory for permutations, dependency edgeR
Acceptance Criteria
Dependency status — refreshed 2026-09-22
Blocked by AnalysisConfig v1 — that blocker is stale and has been removed.
AnalysisConfig v1 shipped (#9 closed 2026-09-18); the layer is live in
src/analysis/AnalysisConfig.jl and passes 83 assertions on every CI run. Nothing was
waiting on it any more.
What actually stands between this issue and implementation is the validated statistics
layer (#1), and the bounded method catalogue that issue requires. That catalogue was
approved on 2026-09-22 and this issue is its item 4, deliberately excluded from v1:
Fisher's exact, exact negative binomial and permutation PERMANOVA are named in the
catalogue as the work that comes after the approved v1 scope, not alongside it.
So the position here is a decision, not a missing dependency — and it should be
recorded as one. Un-deferring means running this work through the same discipline #1
imposes on every other method: published supported/unsupported conditions, known-answer
and independent-reference tests (the R fisher.test comparison above is exactly that),
negative controls, performance benchmarks against the declared risk, and an owner
decision to open the stage. #2 sets the standard for how that gate is written down: a
closed prerequisite or a green test suite is not on its own sufficient.
See docs/milestones/02-deferred-issues.md for full spec.
Scientific Value
Parametric approximations break down with n<10 or sparse features. Exact tests provide valid inference.
Scope (Deferred)
Difficulty: Hard
Risks: Performance 10-100x slower, memory for permutations, dependency edgeR
Acceptance Criteria
Dependency status — refreshed 2026-09-22
Blocked by AnalysisConfig v1— that blocker is stale and has been removed.AnalysisConfig v1 shipped (#9 closed 2026-09-18); the layer is live in
src/analysis/AnalysisConfig.jland passes 83 assertions on every CI run. Nothing waswaiting on it any more.
What actually stands between this issue and implementation is the validated statistics
layer (#1), and the bounded method catalogue that issue requires. That catalogue was
approved on 2026-09-22 and this issue is its item 4, deliberately excluded from v1:
Fisher's exact, exact negative binomial and permutation PERMANOVA are named in the
catalogue as the work that comes after the approved v1 scope, not alongside it.
So the position here is a decision, not a missing dependency — and it should be
recorded as one. Un-deferring means running this work through the same discipline #1
imposes on every other method: published supported/unsupported conditions, known-answer
and independent-reference tests (the
R fisher.testcomparison above is exactly that),negative controls, performance benchmarks against the declared risk, and an owner
decision to open the stage. #2 sets the standard for how that gate is written down: a
closed prerequisite or a green test suite is not on its own sufficient.
See docs/milestones/02-deferred-issues.md for full spec.