Repository navigation
al-agents-review: derive the target BC version from app.json - #231
Stefano Demiliani (demiliani) wants to merge 1 commit into
Conversation
All Agents articles are version-gated ([27..] or [28..]). Without a target version every one stays conditionally applicable and its findings are capped at medium confidence. Align the Relevance section with the Microsoft leaves: when the orchestrator supplies no version, use the major version of the app.json application field. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
Hi Jesper Schulz-Wedde (@JesperSchulz), could you take a look at this one? It's a one-sentence change in Context: almost every review leaf already takes the target BC version from the app's This PR aligns its Relevance section with the other leaves. #229 contains the same fix for the proposed Thanks! |
Why
Almost every review leaf already resolves the target BC version from the consuming app's
app.jsonwhen the orchestrator doesn't supply one. For example,al-query-reviewandal-reporting-reviewsay "Use the target version fromapp.jsonwhen available", andal-scm-reviewuses the application major version from the host context.al-agents-reviewdoesn't. Its Relevance section only says to match "the target BC version", so in a standalone plugin review the version is usually unknown.That matters more here than anywhere else: all 20 Agents articles are version-gated (
[27..]or[28..]). With an unknown version, every one is conditionally applicable, findings are capped atmediumconfidence, and every message has to name the unknown dimension, even when the app'sapp.jsonclearly targets BC27+.What
One sentence in
community/skills/review/al-agents-review.md→ Relevance: when no target version is supplied, use the major version of theapplicationfield in the consuming app'sapp.json; otherwise the dimension stays unknown. There is no change to READ semantics, outputs, or other skills.The same fix is applied to the proposed
al-copilot-reviewin #229.Validation
.github/scripts/Test-SkillIndex.ps1andtools/Test-ReviewFixtures.ps1(including-PrepareDirectory): PASSED.🤖 Generated with Claude Code