[PM seat] domain:skills — ⏳ vacant

[huangyiirene]

This post is the single authoritative registration of the skills seat (seat 1, domain:skills#1). Four-section template; the job description is versioned at .claude/skills/pm-dispatch/references/lanes/skills.md — ⛔ not copied here. Body r130, written 2026-10-02T21:11Z by session_01FNKm1SmPpuJASnbjxWGtsJ (os-elon-musk) at 收班 on the maintainer's word 「当前任务处理完就下班」: the seat is vacant, two Tier H PRs are left on watch. r129 (standby after wave 7) and earlier revisions are in the edit history, ⛔ not restated; carried lists stay carried BY REFERENCE.

Current PM

⏳ vacant · former: session_01FNKm1SmPpuJASnbjxWGtsJ (os-elon-musk), seated 2026-10-01T23:30Z on the maintainer's /pm-dispatch skills as seat 1, stood down 2026-10-02T21:11Z. Patrol Routine trig_01WFQtjRgmMXutRBsd7CAJyd deleted at 收班; no seat Routine is live. 留守 (the departing session, named items only): PR objectstack-ai/objectui#11480 and PR objectstack-ai/objectui#11507 stay subscribed by session_01FNKm1SmPpuJASnbjxWGtsJ, which lands and closes them out on approval; it reads no queue and dispatches nothing. Hand-over: /pm-dispatch skills + read this post, then objectstack-ai/objectui#11311 (the lane's objectui board, same seat); the release marker is the 收班简报 comment below this body.

Inherited + running ledger

• Queue snapshot (2026-10-02T21:11Z, pm:queue ∩ domain:skills): objectstack 1 — finding(pm): check-widening-tells T2 reads identifiers in a multi-line import list as "a new member of a closed set" — a by-reference narrowing that only adds imports is forced to declare Clause-②: yes #21465 (p3 bug tooling area:devpath, graded 2026-10-02T20:54Z: scripts/pm/check-widening-tells.mjs T2 reads a multi-line import list as a closed set; un-dispatched — the stand-down order came first; the next seat's first pick). objectui 0.
• In the landing window (ACCEPTed, Tier H skills/**, awaiting an APPROVED review by os-zhuang / hotlong; both green and mergeable): PR objectui#11480 (objectui#11471, rules/protocol.md's BreakpointColumnMap parenthetical, head 1078b79c, four-piece on since 2026-10-02T15:58Z) · PR objectui#11507 (objectui#11503, guides/project-setup.md's CLI table: the objectui add row deleted, analyze reworded, head 6604f48f, four-piece on since 2026-10-02T20:53Z). After an approval: clear needs-user-decision → relay pr_ready + automerge_enable with --repo objectstack-ai/objectui (unless the approver already did) → confirm MERGED on objectui origin/main by content → strip pm:dispatched + assignee from the card, drop the PR's stale needs-user-decision, landing note. Triage's proposal to fold the two into one PR was declined (reason on objectui#11503's claim 5960912895; the gap is finding(pm): triage may propose folding two governed cards into one PR, or a follow-up pass without a card; the execution protocol has no rule for either — the seat declined both on objectui#11503 by judgment #21467).
• Landed this shift: 15 PRs, 14 cards closed out — objectstack PR pm-dispatch: the claim template spells the ceiling tier by its constant name and cites the --tier MANDATORY path line, never the model id #21269 · fix(scripts): check:i18n-coverage declares the example configs and their src trees to the dispatch derivation #21271 · fix(pm/fleet-write): re-list a lagging issue list before an issue_create read-back says unfound #21278 · fix(pm): issue-transfer confirms a transfer on the target and reads a lagging old URL as a pending redirect #21291 · docs(skills): the dashboards rule stops teaching a per-series override on the compareTo comparison series #21283 · docs(adr-0114): repoint the consumer line at @objectstack/core for the moved import files #21298 · docs(skills): objectstack-ai says guardrails is enforced per turn and output validation lives on action.ai.outputSchema #21302 + docs(protocol): the actions.mdx outputSchema bullet says the cloud AI runtime validates the action result #21303 · fix(pm): fleet-write relay reports created and moved card numbers as check-run annotations; the read-backs read them first #21312 · docs(adr): ADR-0128 §4 dated note — the keyed-digest break did not carry D1, and why #21343 · docs(skills): the upgrade skill's v17-canonical Lead declares its select options #21402; objectui PR Field designer form still offers 'Set null' for a master_detail's deleteBehavior — a choice #9689 makes a publish-time rejection #11410 · fix(build): declare content/** as an input of @objectstack/docs#build #11418 · [finding] os-dev.md states the --workspace-concurrency placement rule unscoped, but pnpm 10 rejects the flag on install — two devs burned a cycle on it in one round #11419 · finding(objectql): record file-field hydration still drops any non-committed sys_file, so it and the download path now answer the tombstone question differently #11427 (cards, heads and notes enumerated in r129). Every Tier H PR (eight) was approved and readied / enqueued by os-zhuang himself.
• Decision box (this lane): 0. Blocked: [finding] objectui's half-state findings reach no reader: the board has no anchor by ruling, and its copy of check-half-states still refuses in agent containers with the conclusion #13544 disproved #18290 (Blocked-by: #18471, still open) · finding(skills): objectstack-ai's Common Pitfalls says "memory is declared only — no runtime reads it"; once PR #21413 lands, the cloud AI runtime enforces it and the spec refuses its old shapes #21415 (p2, Blocked-by: #20274; objectstack-ai's Common Pitfalls line on memory goes stale when PR feat(spec)!: an agent's memory contract states exactly what the runtime honours — maxEntries and reflectionInterval are required once long-term memory is enabled, longTerm.store is retired, and the block is live #21413 lands — the unlock scan places it back). Findings bare: finding(metadata): 索引声明词表无法表达 partial/NULL-safe 形(knex table.unique() 上限)——overlay 索引的双形分歧由 carve-out 顶着,词表加宽零实测拉动,存档待第二个消费者 #13562 (metadata, status:parked, not this lane's) · finding(pm): triage may propose folding two governed cards into one PR, or a follow-up pass without a card; the execution protocol has no rule for either — the seat declined both on objectui#11503 by judgment #21467 (filed at 收班 by this seat: the fold / un-carded-pass gap — the skills seat grades it).
• Cross-lane memos: objectui#11500 (domain:ui, now dispatched by that seat) retires create plugin / lint / test / studio; when it lands, skills/objectui/guides/project-setup.md's CLI table owes the same pass — a card, not a bare grep (finding(pm): triage may propose folding two governed cards into one PR, or a follow-up pass without a card; the execution protocol has no rule for either — the seat declined both on objectui#11503 by judgment #21467). Watch items spec: gate (b) of build-schemas.ts tells an author to paste RETIRED_KEYS_BY_MAJOR lines into migrations/registry.ts, which is generated from entries/ since #7297; two guidance-slot docblocks describe the old retirement route (spec half of #20803) #20809 and #20802 analytics half (domain:services): the cube read and the analytics read scope answer { relation: { field: value } } as the engine seam now serves it — as the caller, capped, one answer on every face #20887 closed 2026-10-01 (PR fix(spec): registration remedies name the entry file and gen:migration-registry, never the generated registry.ts #21021 / PR fix(service-analytics)!: the analytics native-SQL path declines an object an engine middleware is registered for, so its read gates apply #21170 merged): the next seat checks once whether skills/objectstack-upgrade (the retirement kit's RETIRED_KEYS_BY_MAJOR wording) and skills/objectstack-ai/SKILL.md (its analytics line) now owe a sentence; this seat did not. finding(pm tooling): check:pm-issue-transfer is declared in package.json but no workflow runs it — the issue-transfer self-test (63 cases) is enforced only by hand; wire it into the pm roster or remove the entry #21295 (check:pm-issue-transfer wiring) closed in the spec lane.
• Cross-lane declaration received (knock 5955822785, 2026-10-02T15:36Z, domain:services seat 2, seat post [PM seat] domain:services · seat 2 — 🟢 os-bill · session_01DiCSbmJrkzNhuEAier4VoJ · R1 #21118): [Decision] share-links mint authority: the owner of a record on an access: private object can never mint a share link — admit the share-manager (canManageShares) beside the visibility read? (amends ADR-0111 D8 rule 1) #21329 (ruled A′, director batch 🔗 Broken links detected in documentation #268) is dispatched with one governed cross-lane surface, docs/adr/0111-record-share-management-authority-and-verb-boundary.md (D8 rule 1 restated), in PR fix(plugin-sharing): the record owner and an explicit Modify-All holder may mint a share link without visibility (ADR-0111 D8 rule 1, ruling A′) #21447 — Tier H, held for the maintainer's own approval with that seat's final 维护者速读 and both approvers requested; no skills/** file in it. ⛔ Not a request for work; an objection would go on [Decision] share-links mint authority: the owner of a record on an access: private object can never mint a share link — admit the share-manager (canManageShares) beside the visibility read? (amends ADR-0111 D8 rule 1) #21329 before approval. This seat read it at 收班 and raises none; the next seat owes nothing on it beyond awareness.
• Filed this shift (all graded or closed since, except the last): finding(pm tooling): a cloud seat cannot read the numbers a fleet-write run reports — job logs 403 through the proxy, check-run output.summary null; emit issue_create / transfer results as check-run annotations (closure card, 2 sightings) #21294 (landed as PR fix(pm): fleet-write relay reports created and moved card numbers as check-run annotations; the read-backs read them first #21312) · finding(pm tooling): check:pm-issue-transfer is declared in package.json but no workflow runs it — the issue-transfer self-test (63 cases) is enforced only by hand; wire it into the pm roster or remove the entry #21295 (spec lane, closed) · objectui#11414 (landed as PR objectui#11418) · finding(pm): triage may propose folding two governed cards into one PR, or a follow-up pass without a card; the execution protocol has no rule for either — the seat declined both on objectui#11503 by judgment #21467 (bare, at 收班).
• Premise corrections on record (claim / ACCEPT ids in r129): pm-dispatch: a claim's Container & model: line can only be spelled with a model identifier, which objectui's AGENTS.md bans in comments — two rules conflict on every governed sister-repo claim #21048 · finding(pm): dispatch-gates never derives check:i18n-coverage for an edit under examples/ — the gate lints each example config, whose imports span the whole example tree, but its population roots are undeclared #21011 · objectui#11414 · docs(adr): ADR-0114's consumer line still names @objectstack/rest's import-coerce.ts / import-runner.ts, which PR #21084 moved to @objectstack/core #21107 · finding(skills, docs): published AI-author text still describes guardrails as unenforced and outputSchema as never validated; the cloud AI runtime now enforces both (objectstack-ai SKILL.md, actions.mdx) #21288.

Hot-file serial queue

• skills/objectstack-ui/rules/dashboards.md: FREE (PR docs(skills): the dashboards rule stops teaching unread widget options extras #21205 merged). scripts/pm/dispatch-gates.mjs: FROZEN (ruling 208 R6). Every other file of the lane on this board: FREE. objectui: skills/objectui/rules/protocol.md → PR objectui#11480 and skills/objectui/guides/project-setup.md → PR objectui#11507, both this seat's, in the landing window ([PM seat] domain:skills @ objectui — ⏳ vacant objectui#11311).

Notes

• Job description and write paths. references/lanes/skills.md; content writes only through scripts/pm/post-stamped.mjs / label-write.mjs / issue-create.mjs / close-cards.mjs and fleet-write/dispatch.mjs --actions-file (all accept --repo objectstack-ai/objectui); a body refresh needs --ack-through=ID. Route this shift: dispatch (relay fleet-write.yml on main, Actions active).
• Landing. Tier H = an authorized APPROVED review, then the seat clears needs-user-decision and lands (pr_ready + automerge_enable), unless the approver already did; Tier S (.claude/**) = at-tier review PASS then the seat lands; non-governed = CI + the seat's read. Landing = MERGED through the queue (added_to_merge_queue on the timeline, then MERGED confirmed by content on origin/main). Fixes #N closed the card on every one of this shift's 15 queue merges.
• Sister-repo claims. objectui's AGENTS.md bans model identifiers in comments; the recogniser accepts model: CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER with MANDATORY cited on the same line — used on every objectui claim this shift.
• Platform readings (for the next seat): ① write-pace (40 writes / trailing hour) is per container token and SHARED by the seat and every dev it runs; with 3 devs in flight the budget binds (exit 10 = refused, nothing written; the tool prints the reopen instant). ② post-stamped refuses a bare YYYY-MM-DDThh:mmZ quoted from a brief unless wrapped as a declared reading (MIXED, exit 2); flags take the = form. ③ Container Node v22.22.0 is below jsdom@30's ^22.22.2 floor under objectui's engine-strict — devs install with --config.engine-strict=false (deviation recorded each time). ④ Inside a subagent, the auto-mode permission classifier refused a dev's label-write stroke on PR docs(skills): the dashboards rule stops teaching a per-series override on the compareTo comparison series #21283 and PR docs(skills): the upgrade skill's v17-canonical Lead declares its select options #21402 and one gh api … GET; nothing was written; the seat does not perform a refused dev write on the dev's behalf — it surfaces it. Both PRs merged regardless (Check Changeset is not required in the merge group); the two objectui devs of waves 8–9 saw no refusal. ⑤ The container cannot read a fleet-write run's job log (302 → blob, CONNECT 403) or output.summary; annotations are readable — finding(pm tooling): a cloud seat cannot read the numbers a fleet-write run reports — job logs 403 through the proxy, check-run output.summary null; emit issue_create / transfer results as check-run annotations (closure card, 2 sightings) #21294 → PR fix(pm): fleet-write relay reports created and moved card numbers as check-run annotations; the read-backs read them first #21312, and the first live reading is in: issue-create.mjs took finding(pm): triage may propose folding two governed cards into one PR, or a follow-up pass without a card; the execution protocol has no rule for either — the seat declined both on objectui#11503 by judgment #21467's number from run 37064349969's annotation (「the platform's own answer」), no list fallback. ⑥ A cloud session reads only repositories attached to it; the GitHub search API is unavailable (repo-scoped endpoints only), so dedupe runs over repo-scoped lists. ⑦ post-stamped refuses a ## Contract review whose Local-runs: line is outside the closed set none / probe — REASON. ⑧ fleet-write validate refuses an actions file packed as an object rather than a bare array (zero writes; the dev repacked) — the guard works as documented.
• Checkout: /home/user/objectstack and /home/user/objectui were fast-forwarded to origin/main on every patrol; the mirror branch claude/zealous-tesla-zsd0xu on both carries no seat content.

[huangyiirene]

Audit: founding stock transfer executed (devx seat, session session_01GZKbx4xyF7U5WXj6ch49BM, 2026-08-11 ~09:2xZ)

Maintainer instruction (verbatim): 「所有现有 skills 相关卡片转到 新的项目经理」.

Enumeration: swept all open domain:devx cards (26) + a title search for skills/SKILL cards outside the label. 8 transferred — #7548, #7518, #7492, #7493, #7553, #7583, #7512 (borderline, noted on-card), #7498 (in-flight, 改标不改辖). Each carries a provenance comment quoting the instruction; label writes read back — label:domain:skills returns exactly the 8, pm-states intact (7 pm:queue, 1 pm:dispatched).

Deliberately NOT transferred (recorded so the boundary is auditable): QA-checklist authoring cards (#7547, #7573, #7569, #7530 — docs/qa/**, not a skills root), scripts/pm tooling findings (#7412), CI-gate/docs findings (#7484, #7353, #7347, #7329, #7009), and the rest of the devx stock — they stay domain:devx. domain:skills was auto-minted by the first label write; color/description cosmetics + the SKILL domain-table row land with #7548's PR.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-help]

Audit: seat takeover

• Incoming PM: os-help, session session_01ATJiqhFNL82YwV8udPkoqX, 2026-08-11.
• Staffing authority: the maintainer invoked /pm-dispatch skills in this session — the dedicated PM session the founding note (⏳ vacant, "awaiting the maintainer's staffing") was waiting for.
• Same-stroke triple: title → 🟢 os-help, assignee → os-help, body 当前 PM section → the triple above. Queue table refreshed to post-ruling states (all seven open cards now carry maintainer rulings recorded 08:10Z; decision box empty at takeover).
• First-round plan: consolidated batch of the seven ruled cards, one PR, mode:cloud, model: claude-fable-5, dispatched the moment PR pm-dispatch SKILL: require a four-lens block on every needs-user-decision card, Blocked-by-aware batch selection, round-brief decision flags #7552 (the only in-flight SKILL.md PR, awaiting the maintainer's manual merge) reaches terminal state. Round report goes to the maintainer in chat.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-help]

Audit: seat stood down → ⏳ vacant (founding PM, session session_01ATJiqhFNL82YwV8udPkoqX)

Maintainer instruction, verbatim (专题讨论, 2026-08-11): 「fable 5 没token了。剩余的任务开 issue 我让其他人处理」.

Exit checklist executed:

1. New dispatches stopped on receipt.
2. In-flight cleared to zero — PR pm-dispatch SKILL batch: eight ruled amendments — four-lens block, ADR-class skills, three-query board, queue criteria, five shift lessons, claim spelling, seat-post bounds, dispatch-contract rank (#7631) #7698 landed (all 8 member cards closed); its cloud dev session session_01KCFsFypEHm1Cnp26yAofxg archived.
3. Remaining work filed, not carried in context — pm-dispatch SKILL structural compression: 3050 → ~1400–1600 lines (PR₂ of batch #7631, maintainer-directed) #7754 (PR₂ compression, with the directive verbatim, measured composition, method, ⛔ no-rule-deletion constraint, gates, tier); [finding] A skills-root PR was queued by a sibling session ~1h after the ADR-class ruling — a ruling recorded only on cards cannot bind sessions that haven't read it #7701 updated with the second incident specimen; batch card [batch] pm-dispatch SKILL consolidated amendments + compression — eight ruled cards, two serialized PRs (skills seat, round 1) #7631 closed with its ledger.
4. Seat body rewritten to the six-section bounded template with the full handover ledger (prior revisions are the archive, per Seat-post protocol: registry bodies grow without bound — bound the live body to current state, move shift narration out #7583).
5. Title / assignee / body updated in one stroke: ⏳ vacant, assignee cleared.
6. Timers cleared — this session's patrol trigger trig_01SdxKWd2oJfk9gJcAdrdbBk deleted; no orphan PR subscriptions (the two subscribe_pr_activity attempts this session both failed, so none were ever armed).
7. Final report delivered to the maintainer in chat.

Takeover: /pm-dispatch skills, read this post first. Next action for an incoming PM is #7754.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-zhuang]

Audit: seat takeover

• Incoming PM: os-zhuang, session session_01XoWxhuq3WNNaZUTs6kWdk8, 2026-08-11 ~12:5xZ.
• Staffing authority: the maintainer invoked /pm-dispatch skills in this session — the takeover path the stand-down comment above prescribes.
• Same-stroke triple: title → 🟢 os-zhuang, assignee → os-zhuang, body 当前 PM section → the triple above.
• State read at takeover: queue = pm-dispatch SKILL structural compression: 3050 → ~1400–1600 lines (PR₂ of batch #7631, maintainer-directed) #7754 only (premise re-verified against origin/main: SKILL.md = 3050 lines, last touch = PR pm-dispatch SKILL batch: eight ruled amendments — four-lens block, ADR-class skills, three-query board, queue criteria, five shift lessons, claim spelling, seat-post bounds, dispatch-contract rank (#7631) #7698 merged today); finding [finding] A skills-root PR was queued by a sibling session ~1h after the ADR-class ruling — a ruling recorded only on cards cannot bind sessions that haven't read it #7701 held for the triage seat; decision inbox empty; zero open PRs touch either skills root; hot-file queue on SKILL.md empty.
• First action: claim + dispatch pm-dispatch SKILL structural compression: 3050 → ~1400–1600 lines (PR₂ of batch #7631, maintainer-directed) #7754 — mode:cloud, model: claude-fable-5 (mandatory clause). Its PR is ADR-class: this seat reviews but never merges/enqueues/arms auto-merge; round reports will carry the "awaiting a human merge" line.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[huangyiirene]

跨席知会(devx 席 → skills 席):一个 skills-path PR 进入你的人工通道队列。

PR #7837 — [skills-path 人工合并] docs(skill): dogfood §2 — a drifted console dist now refuses to boot (#7752),分支 claude/issue-7752-skill-note,draft。

出处:#7752(console dist 漂移)的实现 PR #7783 原本把 .claude/skills/dogfood-verification/SKILL.md 的一小段和 CLI 代码混在一起。按维护者 2026-08-11「skills 更新与 ADR 同级,需人工审核」的裁决,devx 席未合并,已指令开发拆分:代码半留在 #7783(走 AI 正常流程,已武装),skills 半独立成 #7837 交你席位。

内容:#7783 让 os dev 在 console dist 的 objectui 戳记 ≠ .objectui-sha pin 时拒绝挂载 /_console(而非仅告警后照常服务)。SKILL.md §2 的配套改动是告诉跑手:此后 /_console/ 返回 404 意味着「用 pnpm objectui:build 重建」,不是「console 坏了」。同源的 RUNNER.md 那一行不在 skills 路径下,已留在 #7783 内。

时序建议(非指令,你席位自决):#7837 描述的是 #7783 落地后的行为。若 #7783 先合入而 #7837 待人工审核,期间跑手看到 404 会缺少这条解释 —— RUNNER.md 的 trap 行(在 #7783 内)已覆盖同一提示,所以缺口有限。

devx 席不再持有 #7837,不会对它做任何写操作。

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-zhuang]

Audit: seat takeover

• Incoming PM: os-zhuang, session session_012Gg6rMAti8ZaueWb6BRsDn, 2026-08-12 ~01:5xZ.
• Staffing authority: the maintainer invoked /pm-dispatch skills in this session.
• Predecessor (same account, session session_01XoWxhuq3WNNaZUTs6kWdk8) left no stand-down comment — treated as an ungraceful session end; its ledger was inherited from the seat body and re-verified against live state before the body edit.
• Same-stroke triple: title unchanged (🟢 os-zhuang, same account), assignee unchanged, body 当前 PM section → the triple above.
• State re-verified at takeover: PR docs(pm-dispatch): cloud-card comms is event-driven by ruling — notes-21 verify-before-toggle, PR subscription as hard step #7794 open draft, CI fully green (Check Changeset re-ran to success 15:30Z) — awaiting a human merge. PR [skills-path 人工合并] docs(skill): dogfood §2 — a drifted console dist now refuses to boot (#7752) #7837 (devx transfer) reviewed this round against fix(cli): refuse to serve a drifted vendored console under os dev (#7752) #7783's MERGED diff, skip-changeset applied + failed job re-queued to success shape — awaiting a human merge. pm-dispatch SKILL: 5-hour usage-limit outages — queryable signals, cross-wall recovery timer (hourly cron, not send_later chains), wall-death playbook anchor #7765 / pm-dispatch SKILL Guardrails: dangling sentence fragment "someone else, never dispatch a needs-user-decision issue." — the bullet it belonged to is lost #7767 queued behind docs(pm-dispatch): cloud-card comms is event-driven by ruling — notes-21 verify-before-toggle, PR subscription as hard step #7794 (same-file serial). [finding] A skills-root PR was queued by a sibling session ~1h after the ADR-class ruling — a ruling recorded only on cards cannot bind sessions that haven't read it #7701 held for the triage seat. Decision inbox empty.
• Housekeeping executed: eight closed member cards' stale pm:queue stripped; read back clean (all 10 closed domain:skills cards carry the domain label only).
• Timers: predecessor heartbeat trig_01PA8om7ACs16icXhnXsaEXE already absent (delete → not-found); new cross-wall heartbeat trig_0139XfCW1b1oY5g6T6KeHkVg (hourly, self-bind) armed. docs(pm-dispatch): cloud-card comms is event-driven by ruling — notes-21 verify-before-toggle, PR subscription as hard step #7794 subscribed; [skills-path 人工合并] docs(skill): dogfood §2 — a drifted console dist now refuses to boot (#7752) #7837 subscription rejected by the platform — heartbeat covers it.

---

Generated by Claude Code