Densify SemIf rename + MLX + accuracy ladder by 24601 · Pull Request #37 · 24601/Augustus

24601 · 2026-09-20T15:32:48Z

Adversarial-review reconstruction of the SemIf densify onto latest main after merged #34 (Pages), merged #35 (hourly 0843 / §114), merged #36 (NanoJev / §115), and merged #38 (jcr / §116). Docs/skill only. invented_signal: false. Do not merge from this agent.

Hard rules

Do not reopen or amend merged PR Fold hourly 0042 HIGH: jev-readout, jevify, laya-jev-lab #23–Fold TianyuCodings/NanoJev unified-games-v1 densify #36 or Fold HIGH NiazMorshed2007/jcr: capability-tree lookup, does not execute #38.
Do not push onto open Post-#35 hygiene: §114 citation, scannable dumps, hop-ECE interleave #39 (post-Fold hourly 0843 HIGH: hysteresis, instruct-tuning ECE, calibration does not compose #35 hygiene; IDs unchanged §114) or Fold HIGH alexwestco/llm-to-jev: conversion assistant on-ramp #40 (llm-to-jev; claims §118 / items 322–329 / batch #101).
IDs: this fold remains notes.md §117 / findings batch #100. Composition stays 330–336 (not 315–321): merged Fold HIGH NiazMorshed2007/jcr: capability-tree lookup, does not execute #38 owns 309–316 and open Fold HIGH alexwestco/llm-to-jev: conversion assistant on-ramp #40 took 322–329. Merged Fold hourly 0843 HIGH: hysteresis, instruct-tuning ECE, calibration does not compose #35 owns §114 / 289–302 / #97. Merged Fold TianyuCodings/NanoJev unified-games-v1 densify #36 owns §115 / 303–308 / #98. Merged Fold HIGH NiazMorshed2007/jcr: capability-tree lookup, does not execute #38 owns §116 / 309–316 / #99.

What landed

Not a first sighting. TheoLeeCJ/SemIf densify of rename + MLX + accuracy ladder (already in census / JevBench §78). Quote theirs.

Live REST (review relock this pass): MIT; homepage openjev.com; default master; 2282★ / 140 forks; size 9177; HEAD ca3ba65f1429 (Tolerate float roundoff in MLX evidence verification, 2026-09-19). README SHA 74ab7f7f. Pulse vs §113 2241★: +41. Pulse vs §114 2237★: +45. Cousin zhihz/openjev 19★. Prior 2275★ lock was live-REST drift and is relocked to 2282★.

SemIf IS formerly OpenJev; independent; not affiliated with Jev or TypeSafe.
Interface pattern reproduction with open models; does not reproduce Jev undisclosed model/training.
Direct option logits; 0 output tokens; shared-state parallel; MLX backend (--backend mlx) — backend, not a new species. Do not copy pip.
Speed theirs Qwen3.5-4B 3090: direct 1.023s vs AR JSON 5.332s (5.21×); argmax agree 18/21 — systems comparison ≠ semantic equivalence.
Parallel suffixes 20.03 dec/s on 777 decisions theirs.
Browser ladder theirs: authored BA 0.813, pert 0.766, TypeSafe subset 0.845 vs Published Jev 0.883 (102 across 20 cases).
Softmax over options ≠ calibrated Noul; wire/agreement ≠ replica of TypeSafe.
SemIf ≠ kw2828/OpenJev playground ≠ zhihz/openjev ≠ apiplant/semif-rs port ≠ dddanielliu/semif-serve.
Do not merge this ladder with §78 JevBench 74.6, or re-fold §69 semif-serve.

Overlays: SKILL YAML/protocol/mapping-index, mental-models Apply 0922, FAQ, uniqueness lock as one consecutive substring in 21 overlays, CHANGELOG Unreleased (lock dump in research/changelog-hourly.md). uniqueness_gate.py checks 0843 and 0915 and jcr and 0922 locks, §114+§115+§116+§117, items 289–316 and 330–336 (stolen 317–329 / §118).

Testing

python3 .agents/skills/augustus/scripts/evaluate_decisions.py --self-test
python3 .agents/skills/augustus/scripts/uniqueness_gate.py

Self-test ok. uniqueness-gate ok this pass (0843 chars=2415, 0915 chars=1132, jcr chars=1499, lock0922 chars=1292, overlays=21). SKILL.yaml parses. No live Jev key. No wrappers.

Adversarial self-review: rename is IS not a second census; 5.21× / 18/21 are systems not Harbor; 0.845 is subset agreement not ECE; MLX is a backend; cousins stay ≠; no install recipes; ID uniqueness vs merged #38 and open #40.

Not merged from this agent. Keep moving toward merge with review + the tests above.

Reconstruct PR #37 off latest main after merged #34/#35. Relock live REST 2264★ / zhihz 19★. Keep notes.md §117 / items 315–321 / batch #100; do not steal merged #35 §114 or reserved §115–§116. Extend uniqueness_gate for the 0922 consecutive lock. Docs/skill only. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

24601

Adversarial review + testing gate — PASS

Head d0c08d2b2d38b49e62428a01186baf32b9d21358. Base main 0189825 (merged #35 then #34). mergeable_state: clean. Draft false (ready). Do not merge from this agent.

Original head 092614a FAILed the gate: lock 2251★ vs live 2255+ (now 2264★), zhihz 18★ vs live 19★, and the PR went CONFLICTING after #34/#35 landed. Reconstructed onto current main on this branch and relocked.

Checklist

No invented metrics / live REST drift — PASS. Live REST this review: TheoLeeCJ/SemIf 2264★ / 140 forks / size 9177 / HEAD ca3ba65f1429 (Tolerate float roundoff in MLX evidence verification) / README 74ab7f7f / LICENSE ca562883 / MIT / homepage openjev.com / default master. Cousins: kw2828 1★, zhihz 19★, semif-rs 0★, semif-serve 0★. Speed/ladder figures remain README/docs/MLX.md theirs (1.023s vs 5.332s 5.21×, 18/21, 20.03 dec/s, BA 0.813 / pert 0.766 / subset 0.845 vs Jev 0.883). Pulse vs §113 2241★ is +23; vs §114 2237★ is +27.
Soft Noul never hard gate; Softmax ≠ Noul — PASS. Explicit in §117, Apply 0922, FAQ, YAML, protocol needles. No Noul-as-PR-gate.
No silent fallback / soundness theater; systems≠semantic — PASS. 18/21 quoted as disagreement; 5.21× is systems not TypeSafe latency; 0.845 is subset agreement not ECE/Harbor. No silent fallback theater.
Name collisions / rename honesty / namesakes — PASS. SemIf IS formerly OpenJev (densify, not a second census). ≠ kw2828/OpenJev playground ≠ zhihz/openjev ≠ apiplant/semif-rs ≠ dddanielliu/semif-serve. IamBusy/OpenJev REST resolve to OpenJev-Vision called out, not treated as a §69 deletion.
Quotes theirs vs gloss — PASS. Metrics marked theirs; MLX line “typed output does not guarantee semantic correctness, and softmax scores are not calibrated confidence” is theirs. Hunches labeled. invented_signal: false.
Section ID uniqueness — PASS. This fold is §117 / 315–321 / batch #100. Merged #35 keeps §114 / 289–302 / #97. Open #36 + jcr still own §115–§116 / 303–314 / #98–#99 (not present on this branch). uniqueness_gate fails if §115/§116 headings or items 303–314 appear.
Diff docs/skill only; README scannable; SKILL YAML parses — PASS. 24 files, +602/−17: skill + references + uniqueness_gate.py + CHANGELOG/README/docs/research. No wrappers, no pip recipes. README still one-line-per-file plus lock list + Pages SVG. yaml.safe_load SKILL frontmatter ok (name augustus, version 0.4.0).
TESTING — PASS.
- evaluate_decisions.py --self-test → self-test ok
- uniqueness_gate.py → uniqueness-gate ok (lock0843 chars=2415, lock0922 chars=1280, overlays=21)
- Pages CI Check Pages site / build: success on this head: https://github.com/24601/Augustus/actions/runs/35520771680
  Combined commit status is empty/pending (Scorecard is main-only); the required Pages check is green.

Verdict: PASS. Ready for human merge. Not merged here.

Reconstruct PR #37 after merged #36 (NanoJev §115 / 303–308). Keep notes.md §117 / batch #100. Remap composition 315–321 → 330–336 so open #38 jcr (309–316) and open #40 llm-to-jev (322–329) stay unique. Relock live REST 2266★. Docs/skill only. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

Reconstruct PR #37 onto merged #38 (jcr §116 / 309–316 / #99). Keep §117 / items 330–336 / batch #100. Relock live REST 2275★. Softmax ≠ Noul; 5.21× is systems≠semantic. Do not merge from this agent. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

24601

PASS (adversarial review + testing). Do not merge from this agent.

Head: 47a870a6d31c448ad29373a5414233b3a406eae7
Base: be9fe1c (merged #38 jcr)
Pages CI: success — https://github.com/24601/Augustus/actions/runs/35521989520/job/106107539981
mergeable: CLEAN / MERGEABLE. Draft: false.

Reconstruct / IDs

Merged #35 §114 / 289–302 / #97, #36 §115 / 303–308 / #98, #38 §116 / 309–316 / #99 are on main and kept.
This fold stays notes.md §117 / items 330–336 / batch #100 (not 315–321: jcr overran 315–316; open #40 took 322–329).
Open #39 hygiene (§114 unchanged). Open #40 §118 / 322–329 / #101 reserved (stolen 317–329 / §118).
Do not reopen #23–#36/#38. Do not push onto #39/#40.

Live REST relock (FAIL-block 1)

TheoLeeCJ/SemIf: MIT; homepage openjev.com; default master; 2275★ / 140 forks; size 9177; HEAD ca3ba65f1429 (Tolerate float roundoff in MLX evidence verification, 2026-09-19). README SHA 74ab7f7f; LICENSE SHA ca562883. Prior 2266★ lock was drift; relocked to live 2275★ (+34 vs §113 2241; +38 vs §114 2237). Cousins: zhihz 19★, kw2828 1★, semif-rs 0★, semif-serve 0★.

FAIL-blocks

Metrics theirs / no live-REST drift. 5.21× / 18/21 / 20.03 / BA 0.813 / subset 0.845 vs Jev 0.883 quoted from README SHA 74ab7f7f + docs/MLX.md SHA e1d81a75. Stars match live 2275.
Soft Noul never hard-gate. Softmax-over-options ≠ calibrated Noul. 0.813/0.845/0.883 are sensors, not merge gates.
No silent fallback / soundness theater. 5.21× and 18/21 are systems comparison ≠ semantic equivalence. Wire/agreement ≠ TypeSafe replica. JevBench 74.6 stays §78.
Rename honesty / collisions. SemIf IS formerly OpenJev (densify, not a second census). ≠ kw2828/zhihz/semif-rs/semif-serve. MLX is a backend, not a species.
Quotes theirs vs gloss. README/MLX numbers marked theirs. Hunches labeled. invented_signal: false.
Section ID uniqueness. §114+§115+§116 kept; this fold §117 / 330–336 / #100; §118 / 317–329 stolen.
Diff docs/skill only (24 files, +552/−12). README scannable. SKILL YAML parses (name: augustus, 0.4.0).
Gates green. uniqueness_gate.py ok (0843=2415, 0915=1132, jcr=1499, 0922=1292, overlays=21). evaluate_decisions.py --self-test ok. Pages build success on this SHA.

No pip/install recipes. No wrappers. Skip Archer. Softmax ≠ Noul.

Ready for human merge. Not merged from this agent.

Stars drifted past the 2275 lock during review. Keep IDs §117 / 330–336 / #100 on main after merged #36 and #38. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

24601

PASS (adversarial review + testing). Do not merge from this agent.

Head: fbe0ba5ed3a1c600ca83018ff090224d4bc1b0ea
Base: be9fe1c (merged #38 jcr already on this branch — no further rebase)
Pages CI: success — https://github.com/24601/Augustus/actions/runs/35522160315/job/106107986360
mergeable: CLEAN. Draft: false.

IDs (this FYI)

Merged #38 owns §116 / 309–316 / #99 (kept on main).
This fold is notes.md §117 / items 330–336 / batch #100 — not 315–321.
Merged #35 §114 / 289–302 / #97; merged #36 §115 / 303–308 / #98 kept.
Open #40 §118 / 322–329 / #101 reserved (stolen 317–329 / §118).
Open #41 (hourly 0947) still claims §116 / 309–324 / #99 against merged #38 (mergeable_state: dirty). No collision with 330–336. Do not push onto #39/#40/#41.

Live REST (FAIL-block 1)

TheoLeeCJ/SemIf: MIT; homepage openjev.com; default master; 2282★ / 140 forks; size 9177; HEAD ca3ba65f1429. README SHA 74ab7f7f. Matches lock this pass (2275 was drift; relocked). Pulse vs §113 2241: +41; vs §114 2237: +45.

FAIL-blocks

Metrics theirs / live REST matches 2282. 5.21× / 18/21 / 20.03 / BA 0.813 / subset 0.845 vs Jev 0.883 from README SHA 74ab7f7f.
Softmax-over-options ≠ calibrated Noul. Soft Noul never a hard gate.
5.21× and 18/21 are systems comparison ≠ semantic equivalence. JevBench 74.6 stays §78.
SemIf IS formerly OpenJev (densify). ≠ kw2828/zhihz/semif-rs/semif-serve. MLX is a backend.
Quotes theirs vs gloss. invented_signal: false.
ID uniqueness vs merged #35/#36/#38 and open #40/#41: this fold stays 330–336 / §117.
Diff docs/skill only (24 files). README scannable. SKILL YAML parses (0.4.0).
Gates: uniqueness_gate.py ok (0843=2415, 0915=1132, jcr=1499, 0922=1292, overlays=21). --self-test ok. Pages build success on this SHA.

Ready for human merge. Not merged from this agent.

…ogs and RLCD heads Rebased onto latest main. Remapped IDs past merged #38 jcr and SemIf batch #102. uniqueness_gate checks 0843 + 0915 + jcr + 0947 (and SemIf after keep-both onto #37). Evaluator locks the candidate_mass renormalization trap. Do not reopen #23–#38. Do not push onto open #37/#39/#40. Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Skip Archer. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

…ogs and RLCD heads Rebased onto latest main (501ba28 / merged #37 SemIf after be9fe1c / #38 jcr). Remapped IDs past merged #38/#37 and open #40: notes.md §119 / composition 337–352 / findings batch #102. uniqueness_gate checks 0843 + 0915 + jcr + 0922 + 0947. Evaluator locks the candidate_mass renormalization trap. Do not reopen #23–#38. Do not push onto open #39/#40. Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Skip Archer. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

…ogs and RLCD heads Rebased onto latest main (9824aa2 / merged #40 llm-to-jev after 501ba28 / #37 SemIf after be9fe1c / #38 jcr). Remapped IDs past merged #38/#37/#40: notes.md §119 / composition 337–352 / findings batch #102. uniqueness_gate checks 0843 + 0915 + jcr + 0922 + 0940 + 0947. Evaluator locks the candidate_mass renormalization trap. Do not reopen #23–#40. Do not push onto open #39. Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Skip Archer. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

…CE interleave Rebased onto latest main after merged #36/#38/#37/#40 (9824aa2). Do not reopen or amend #23–#40. Do not push onto open #41. Follow-up off main: ecosystem 0843 cited notes.md §113; README and CHANGELOG Unreleased still held dump walls; the 0843 lock ended at #33. Restore v0.4.0 scannability (dumps live in changelog-hourly). Extend the 0843 uniqueness lock through merged #34 and #35. Hop-ECE self-test covers reverse and even/odd interleave. uniqueness_gate checks Pages strings and refuses CHANGELOG/README dump walls. IDs unchanged: notes.md §114 / composition 289–302 / findings batch #97. Merged #31 still owns §113 / 273–288 / #96. Later folds keep §115–§118. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

…CE interleave (#39) Rebased onto latest main after merged #36/#38/#37/#40 (9824aa2). Do not reopen or amend #23–#40. Do not push onto open #41. Follow-up off main: ecosystem 0843 cited notes.md §113; README and CHANGELOG Unreleased still held dump walls; the 0843 lock ended at #33. Restore v0.4.0 scannability (dumps live in changelog-hourly). Extend the 0843 uniqueness lock through merged #34 and #35. Hop-ECE self-test covers reverse and even/odd interleave. uniqueness_gate checks Pages strings and refuses CHANGELOG/README dump walls. IDs unchanged: notes.md §114 / composition 289–302 / findings batch #97. Merged #31 still owns §113 / 273–288 / #96. Later folds keep §115–§118. Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

…ogs and RLCD heads Rebased onto latest main (9824aa2 / merged #40 llm-to-jev after 501ba28 / #37 SemIf after be9fe1c / #38 jcr). Remapped IDs past merged #38/#37/#40: notes.md §119 / composition 337–352 / findings batch #102. uniqueness_gate checks 0843 + 0915 + jcr + 0922 + 0940 + 0947. Evaluator locks the candidate_mass renormalization trap. Do not reopen #23–#40. Do not push onto open #39. Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Skip Archer. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

…ogs and RLCD heads (#41) Rebased onto latest main (9824aa2 / merged #40 llm-to-jev after 501ba28 / #37 SemIf after be9fe1c / #38 jcr). Remapped IDs past merged #38/#37/#40: notes.md §119 / composition 337–352 / findings batch #102. uniqueness_gate checks 0843 + 0915 + jcr + 0922 + 0940 + 0947. Evaluator locks the candidate_mass renormalization trap. Do not reopen #23–#40. Do not push onto open #39. Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Skip Archer. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

cursor Bot force-pushed the cursor/densify-semif-rename-mlx-ladder-1d85 branch from 092614a to d0c08d2 Compare September 20, 2026 15:49

24601 commented Sep 20, 2026

View reviewed changes

24601 mentioned this pull request Sep 20, 2026

Fold HIGH alexwestco/llm-to-jev: conversion assistant on-ramp #40

Merged

cursor Bot mentioned this pull request Sep 20, 2026

Fold HIGH NiazMorshed2007/jcr: capability-tree lookup, does not execute #38

Merged

cursor Bot force-pushed the cursor/densify-semif-rename-mlx-ladder-1d85 branch from d0c08d2 to ca7a1cf Compare September 20, 2026 16:02

cursor Bot force-pushed the cursor/densify-semif-rename-mlx-ladder-1d85 branch from ca7a1cf to 47a870a Compare September 20, 2026 16:12

24601 commented Sep 20, 2026

View reviewed changes

24601 mentioned this pull request Sep 20, 2026

Fold hourly 0947 HIGH: jev-as-judge, OneForward candidate_mass, catalogs and RLCD heads #41

Merged

Relock SemIf live REST 2282★ on §117 densify.

fbe0ba5

Stars drifted past the 2275 lock during review. Keep IDs §117 / 330–336 / #100 on main after merged #36 and #38. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>

24601 commented Sep 20, 2026

View reviewed changes

24601 merged commit 501ba28 into main Sep 20, 2026
1 check passed

24601 deleted the cursor/densify-semif-rename-mlx-ladder-1d85 branch September 20, 2026 16:17

24601 mentioned this pull request Sep 20, 2026

Post-#35 hygiene: §114 citation, scannable dumps, hop-ECE interleave #39

Merged

Navigation Menu

Densify SemIf rename + MLX + accuracy ladder - #37

Densify SemIf rename + MLX + accuracy ladder#37
24601 merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
cursor/densify-semif-rename-mlx-ladder-1d85

24601 commented Sep 20, 2026 •

edited by cursor Bot

Loading

Uh oh!

24601 left a comment

Uh oh!

24601 left a comment

Uh oh!

24601 left a comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

2 participants

Conversation

24601 commented Sep 20, 2026 • edited by cursor Bot Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Hard rules

What landed

Testing

Uh oh!

24601 left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Adversarial review + testing gate — PASS

Checklist

Uh oh!

24601 left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Reconstruct / IDs

Live REST relock (FAIL-block 1)

FAIL-blocks

Uh oh!

24601 left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

IDs (this FYI)

Live REST (FAIL-block 1)

FAIL-blocks

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

2 participants

24601 commented Sep 20, 2026 •

edited by cursor Bot

Loading