Fold TianyuCodings/NanoJev unified-games-v1 densify - #36
Conversation
24601
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
PASS adversarial review + testing gate for Augustus #36 at 7390d27.
Docs/skill densify of TianyuCodings/NanoJev unified-games-v1. Merged #31 keeps §113 / items 273–288 / batch #96. Open #35 still claims §113; §114 / items 289–302 / batch #97 reserved for that remap. This fold: §115 / items 303–308 / batch #98. Do not reopen #31/#32/#33/#35. Do not bump 0.4.0. Do not merge from this review.
First pass FAIL on live REST drift (lock 1283★ vs GitHub 1284★). Relocked on this branch (7390d27). Quotes from docs/TYPESAFE_CONTRACT.md (repo-root path 404s).
Checklist
- PASS — No invented metrics after relock. Live REST at review matches the uniqueness lock: TianyuCodings/NanoJev 1284★ / 158 forks / size 64035; HEAD
618cea6d906d54e128360786d12f703fff2b1245; README SHA4190093c64ee75b26e9726daa3b00cbcf6d3157a; LICENSE SHAf6cd1f1b6511c81f43c8be48004a53332ed4f73c; id 1374702542; no GH tags/releases. Hub C-Tianyu/NanoJev likes 57 / downloads 1267; main047b927b; tag unified-games-v1456cea98(peeled047b927b); base_model Qwen/Qwen3-0.6B. Dataset likes 5 / downloads 1073; main7afc5257; tagfd4d07b6(peeled7afc5257). Demo HTTP 401. Collision HEADs still3cdad2d21716/9cf503d7e88f/eb3e4a2d.invented_signal: false. - PASS — Soft Noul never hard gate. Game success ≠ calibrated Noul. 128/128 / 4/10 / 8/8 / 27/128 stay gameplay sensors, not Harbor.
- PASS — No silent fallback / soundness theater. Normalized Choice bag ≠ Noul. Maze 4/10 is not a class ceiling. RLCD still unchecked theirs.
- PASS — Name collisions held. caijinchun/nanojev-arena ≠ liao96312/jev-arena-nanojev ≠ zwliJay/jev-forge ≠ TianyuCodings/NanoJev. not TypeSafe Jev; open replica / specialist gameplay S1. ≠ jev-forge §99. Qwen3.8-27B ≠ Archer (skip).
- PASS — Quoted figures are theirs: README headline / “One model, four games” / Basic 128/128 vs Jev 56/128 / Predict 27/128 vs Jev 11/128 / Maze 225 vs Jev 2,738 / Snake 30 food / 256 steps / held-out table / 18,760 / 16,333 / 896 / mix 1/3, 1/3, 1/6, 1/6 /
unified-games-v1=hard_lr1e5step-400. Contract theirs:type: "boolean"; localtype: "noul"fails validation; “A normalized distribution alone does not establish empirical probability calibration.” - PASS — ID uniqueness. #31 keeps §113. No
## 114heading; items 289–302 absent. This PR is §115 / 303–308 / #98. Uniqueness lock endsdo not reopen or amend PR #31/#32/#33/#35; notes.md §115. - PASS — Diff vs
origin/mainis docs/skill/research + CHANGELOG/README only (23 files). SKILL.md YAMLsafe_loads; metadata.version 0.4.0; no YAML surgery. #33 scannable README file map kept; uniqueness lock is one overlay line. 0743 lock unchanged where it existed on main. - PASS — Pages CI green on this head: Check Pages site / build.
evaluate_decisions.py --self-test→self-test ok. Uniqueness-gate →uniqueness-gate ok(lock chars=1132, overlays=21). No uniqueness_gate.py added (docs/skill only).
IDs: notes §115; composition 303–308; findings #98.
Head: 7390d2702172d088b2cf48458ba4b5fb381b847d
CI: Pages build success.
Merge order: #31 is on main; do not merge #36 from this agent. Open #35 remap still owns reserved §114.
|
PASS at
|
Adversarial review head-check: GitHub TianyuCodings/NanoJev is 1284★. Keep uniqueness lock consecutive across 21 overlays. Quote docs/TYPESAFE_CONTRACT.md (README path), not the repo root 404. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
7390d27 to
98f7096
Compare
Adversarial head-check after rebase: GitHub TianyuCodings/NanoJev is 1288★ (+4 vs 1284). Hub C-Tianyu/NanoJev likes 58 (+1 vs 57). Keep the 0915 uniqueness lock consecutive across 21 overlays. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
Adversarial review on 295e6e2: consecutive 0915 lock already has Hub likes 58, but validation.md prose still said 57. Live REST still 1288★ / likes 58. Do not mutate uniqueness_gate.py. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
Adversarial head-check after leftover-likes fix: GitHub TianyuCodings/NanoJev is 1289★. Hub likes 58 held. Keep the 0915 uniqueness lock consecutive across 21 overlays. Do not mutate uniqueness_gate.py. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
24601
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
PASS adversarial review + testing gate for Augustus #36 at 6bf67b3.
Docs/skill densify of TianyuCodings/NanoJev unified-games-v1. Merged #31 keeps §113 / items 273–288 / batch #96. Merged #35 owns §114 / items 289–302 / batch #97. This fold stays §115 / items 303–308 / batch #98. Rebased onto latest main (0189825 / #35); no further main commits. Do not reopen #31/#32/#33/#35. Do not bump 0.4.0. Do not merge from this review.
Supersedes the earlier COMMENT on 7390d27 (pre-rebase IDs still reserved #35 as open). This pass: leftover Hub likes 57 in validation.md prose (lock already 58) then live REST 1288★ → 1289★. Relocked consecutive 0915 lock on this head.
Checklist
- PASS — No invented metrics after relock. Live REST at review matches the uniqueness lock: TianyuCodings/NanoJev 1289★ / 158 forks / size 64035; HEAD
618cea6d906d54e128360786d12f703fff2b1245; README SHA4190093c64ee75b26e9726daa3b00cbcf6d3157a; LICENSE SHAf6cd1f1b6511c81f43c8be48004a53332ed4f73c; id 1374702542; subscribers 9; open_issues 7; no GH tags/releases. Hub C-Tianyu/NanoJev likes 58 / downloads 1267; main047b927b; tag unified-games-v1456cea98(peeled047b927b); base_model Qwen/Qwen3-0.6B; lastModified2026-09-20T10:19:01.000Z. Dataset likes 5 / downloads 1073; main7afc5257; tagfd4d07b6(peeled7afc5257). Demo HTTP 401. Collision HEADs still3cdad2d21716/9cf503d7e88f/eb3e4a2d.invented_signal: false. - PASS — Soft Noul never hard gate. Game success ≠ calibrated Noul. 128/128 / 4/10 / 8/8 / 27/128 stay gameplay sensors, not Harbor.
- PASS — No silent fallback / soundness theater. Normalized Choice bag ≠ Noul. Maze 4/10 is not a class ceiling. RLCD still unchecked theirs.
- PASS — Name collisions held. caijinchun/nanojev-arena ≠ liao96312/jev-arena-nanojev ≠ zwliJay/jev-forge ≠ TianyuCodings/NanoJev. not TypeSafe Jev; open replica / specialist gameplay S1. ≠ jev-forge §99. Qwen3.8-27B ≠ Archer (skip).
- PASS — Quoted figures are theirs: README headline / “One model, four games” / Basic 128/128 vs Jev 56/128 / Predict 27/128 vs Jev 11/128 / Maze 225 vs Jev 2,738 / Snake 30 food / 256 steps / held-out table / 18,760 / 16,333 / 896 / mix 1/3, 1/3, 1/6, 1/6 /
unified-games-v1=hard_lr1e5step-400. Contract theirs fromdocs/TYPESAFE_CONTRACT.md(repo-root 404):type: "boolean"; localtype: "noul"fails validation; “A normalized distribution alone does not establish empirical probability calibration.” - PASS — ID uniqueness. #31 keeps §113. #35 keeps §114 / 289–302 / #97. No
## 116. This PR is §115 / 303–308 / #98 (composition 288 then 289–302 then 303–308). Uniqueness lock endsdo not reopen or amend PR #31/#32/#33/#35; notes.md §115. - PASS — Diff vs
origin/mainis docs/skill/research + CHANGELOG/README only (23 files, +640/−21). SKILL.md YAMLsafe_loads; metadata.version 0.4.0; body-only overlay, no YAML surgery. #33 scannable README file map kept; uniqueness lock is one overlay line.uniqueness_gate.pyunchanged vs main. 0743 lock still missing only informal-semi-formal.md(pre-existing on main; not backfilled). - PASS — Pages CI green on this head: Check Pages site / build.
evaluate_decisions.py --self-test→self-test ok. Uniqueness-gate →uniqueness-gate ok(0843 lock chars=2415, overlays=21). 0915 lock consecutive (chars=1132, overlays=21). No uniqueness_gate.py in the diff.
IDs: notes §115; composition 303–308; findings #98.
Head: 6bf67b3f23ae04f45adf0dda5b6dd314d81ed730
CI: Pages build success on this SHA.
Merge order: #31 and #35 are on main; do not merge #36 from this agent. PR is ready (draft: false).
|
PASS at
|
…, does not execute Docs/skill only off latest main after merged #34. IDs: notes.md §116 / items 309–316 / batch #99 (skip #36's §115 / 303–308 / #98 and #35 remap §114 / 289–302 / #97). Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…, does not execute Docs/skill only off latest main after merged #34. IDs: notes.md §116 / items 309–316 / batch #99 (skip #36's §115 / 303–308 / #98 and #35 remap §114 / 289–302 / #97). Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
Reconstruct PR #37 after merged #36 (NanoJev §115 / 303–308). Keep notes.md §117 / batch #100. Remap composition 315–321 → 330–336 so open #38 jcr (309–316) and open #40 llm-to-jev (322–329) stay unique. Relock live REST 2266★. Docs/skill only. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…, does not execute (#38) Docs/skill only off latest main after merged #34. IDs: notes.md §116 / items 309–316 / batch #99 (skip #36's §115 / 303–308 / #98 and #35 remap §114 / 289–302 / #97). Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
* Densify SemIf rename + MLX + ladder onto main (2275★, §117 / 330–336). Reconstruct PR #37 onto merged #38 (jcr §116 / 309–316 / #99). Keep §117 / items 330–336 / batch #100. Relock live REST 2275★. Softmax ≠ Noul; 5.21× is systems≠semantic. Do not merge from this agent. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Relock SemIf live REST 2282★ on §117 densify. Stars drifted past the 2275 lock during review. Keep IDs §117 / 330–336 / #100 on main after merged #36 and #38. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…CE interleave Rebased onto latest main after merged #36/#38/#37/#40 (9824aa2). Do not reopen or amend #23–#40. Do not push onto open #41. Follow-up off main: ecosystem 0843 cited notes.md §113; README and CHANGELOG Unreleased still held dump walls; the 0843 lock ended at #33. Restore v0.4.0 scannability (dumps live in changelog-hourly). Extend the 0843 uniqueness lock through merged #34 and #35. Hop-ECE self-test covers reverse and even/odd interleave. uniqueness_gate checks Pages strings and refuses CHANGELOG/README dump walls. IDs unchanged: notes.md §114 / composition 289–302 / findings batch #97. Merged #31 still owns §113 / 273–288 / #96. Later folds keep §115–§118. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…CE interleave (#39) Rebased onto latest main after merged #36/#38/#37/#40 (9824aa2). Do not reopen or amend #23–#40. Do not push onto open #41. Follow-up off main: ecosystem 0843 cited notes.md §113; README and CHANGELOG Unreleased still held dump walls; the 0843 lock ended at #33. Restore v0.4.0 scannability (dumps live in changelog-hourly). Extend the 0843 uniqueness lock through merged #34 and #35. Hop-ECE self-test covers reverse and even/odd interleave. uniqueness_gate checks Pages strings and refuses CHANGELOG/README dump walls. IDs unchanged: notes.md §114 / composition 289–302 / findings batch #97. Merged #31 still owns §113 / 273–288 / #96. Later folds keep §115–§118. Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
User-linked HIGH densify of TianyuCodings/NanoJev unified-games-v1 (2026-09-20 ~09:15 Boise). Rebased onto latest
mainafter merged #35 (0189825, hourly 0843).Hard rules
notes.md§113 / items 273–288 / batch #96. Merged Fold hourly 0843 HIGH: hysteresis, instruct-tuning ECE, calibration does not compose #35 owns §114 / items 289–302 / batch #97. This fold stays §115 / items 303–308 / batch #98.Docs/skill only. No wrappers,
pip,snapshot_download,serve_decisions, or UNIFIED_GAMES bash. Skip Archer.invented_signal: false.What landed
research/notes.md§115, composition items 303–308 (after 289–302), findings batch #98, SKILL body (no YAML surgery), mental-models Apply 0915, FAQ, mixed-architecture fail table + gallery, judgment-class, validation, formal-methods / formal-semi-formal, uniqueness lock across 21 overlays, CHANGELOG Unreleased (lock dump also inresearch/changelog-hourly.md). Does not bump 0.4.0. Does not mutateuniqueness_gate.py(#35's 0843 gate).This is the unified-games-v1 densify, not a first sighting (already light in §7 / §72 jevinf / ecosystem / faq).
Claim (quote theirs)
hard_lr1e5/ mix 1/3, 1/3, 1/6, 1/6.Live REST locks (review relock ~2026-09-20T15:52Z)
618cea6d906d54e128360786d12f703fff2b1245; README SHA4190093c64ee75b26e9726daa3b00cbcf6d3157a; LICENSE SHAf6cd1f1b; id 1374702542; no GH tags/releases.047b927b; tag unified-games-v1456cea98(peeled047b927b); base_model Qwen/Qwen3-0.6B; gated false.7afc5257; tag unified-games-v1fd4d07b6; hard (default) + soft.https://nanojev-dev.tianyuchen99.chatgpt.site/?autoplay=1HTTP 401 gated. Recordings local theirs. Quotes fromdocs/TYPESAFE_CONTRACT.md(not repo-root 404).Testing
Self-test ok. uniqueness_gate ok (0843 lock chars=2415, overlays=21). 0915 lock ok (chars=1132, overlays=21). No live Jev key.
Not merged from this agent. Keep moving toward merge with review + the tests above.