docs: define repository observation and safe cleanup boundaries - #108
Conversation
pcvantol
left a comment
pcvantol
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Architecture closure review — PROJECT_HYGIENE_AND_REPOSITORY_RECONCILIATION_V1.
Reviewed source: a887ac3. Peers: pcvantol/forge#59, pcvantol/workspace#17, pcvantol/forge-platform#20.
EP retains observation, mutation, admission and finalization authority. Forge cases do not fabricate Missions/Actions/runs. The finalizer correctly retains its own coordinating lease while cleaning proven-delivered resources; only a conflicting owner blocks it, and a separate maintenance command cannot borrow the exception. Conditional expected-ref mutation, recovery retention, ignored/untracked state preservation, scoped actor authorization, duplicate/lost-ack and partial receipts are specified. Cleanup failures do not overwrite proven delivery. All new runtime capabilities remain PLANNED.
Verified exact-head hosted validation run 34323771114: installed wheel, P-TRANSPORT 3x2, deterministic execution E2E, HTTP/OpenAPI/Postman, coverage and four browser shards SUCCESS. Localization job is explicitly SKIPPED for this non-UI change, not claimed PASS. CodeQL, security baseline, Golden and TDE workflows SUCCESS. Separate Owner Authorization status SUCCESS via 34323771350.
Documentary DAG was locally checked against exact Forge JSON Git blob 15453c0d5ef0e8c1e40795cf659541325c53da85: 10 unique nodes, 13 valid edges, acyclic, dependency/status parity, no runtime authority and no new first-canary blocker. No local full-suite or installed-host claim.
Disposition: architecture GO for normal protected squash merge, subject to unchanged head and current repository gates. This COMMENT records review closure; it is not a fabricated independent approval or status. No installation, release, active policy, grant, budget or actual cleanup is changed.
PROJECT_HYGIENE_AND_REPOSITORY_RECONCILIATION_V1 Canonize read-only health/chat, bounded cases without Mission allocation, scoped cleanup proposals and owner-backed decisions. Preserve Forge reasoning and EP execution authority; implementation remains PLANNED. Coordinated with pcvantol/forge#59, pcvantol/engineering-platform#108 and pcvantol/forge-platform#20. Documentation/roadmap only; no runtime activation.
PROJECT_HYGIENE_AND_REPOSITORY_RECONCILIATION_V1 Canonical source/operation-scoped assessment and composition roadmap. Preserve independent artifact, rollback, installation and external CD authority; no global stale-branch gate or installer cleanup bypass. Implementation remains PLANNED. Coordinated with pcvantol/forge#59, pcvantol/engineering-platform#108 and pcvantol/workspace#17. Documentation only; no runtime activation.
PROJECT_HYGIENE_AND_REPOSITORY_RECONCILIATION_V1 Canonize native Forge observations, Branch Provenance Ledger projection, bounded reconciliation cases without Mission allocation, governed residual routing and EP-owned safe cleanup. Add scoped roadmap and documentary DAG (10 nodes / 13 edges); implementation remains PLANNED and no first-canary umbrella gate is added. Coordinated with pcvantol/engineering-platform#108, pcvantol/workspace#17 and pcvantol/forge-platform#20. Documentation only: no runtime, grant, budget, version, installation, release or cleanup activation.
|
Four-repository architecture closure verified: pcvantol/forge#59, this #108, pcvantol/workspace#17 and pcvantol/forge-platform#20 are all merged. Full commit matrix and exact-head qualification references: pcvantol/forge#59 (comment) . EP main read back as b3cd4b2. The finalizer-own-lease clarification is included; no runtime cleanup or capability activation is claimed. HY-0 documentation closed; HY-E/HY-C/HY-Q implementation remains PLANNED. |
|
Coordinated architecture closure is complete: Forge #59 -> b2e4628e432240e13266679343700659b5e1820e; EP #108 -> b3cd4b2; Workspace #17 -> cb27f0eabdda6cca854774f96767161a72f13dad; Forge Platform #20 -> 57ac31ad6a51c5188d266dd3365da568dc33f13e. All owning main refs were read back and matched. Full cross-repository closure: pcvantol/forge#59 (comment) EP exact reviewed head a887ac3 had successful validation (including installed P-TRANSPORT, E2E, contracts, coverage and four browser shards), security/CodeQL/Golden/TDE and separate Owner Authorization before ordinary squash. Optional UI localization was skipped for this non-UI scope, not falsely counted PASS. This closes architecture/documentary roadmap work only. HY-E/HY-C/HY-Q implementation remains PLANNED; no maintenance command, runtime, schema, grant, budget, installation, publication or actual branch cleanup activated. The finalizer's own coordination lease is preserved; cleanup warnings remain separate from proven delivery. |
1 participant
Coordinated architecture increment
PROJECT_HYGIENE_AND_REPOSITORY_RECONCILIATION_V1, coordinated with pcvantol/forge#59 and pcvantol/workspace#17.EP owns fresh bounded repository/host observations and safe execution, reusing current providers, admission, leases and own-run finalization. Project-wide Forge cases do not fabricate Missions/Actions/runs; cleanup is an explicitly authorized typed maintenance request, never an arbitrary shell shortcut.
Defines current actor/scope/ref checks, ownership/adoption, active/protected/retained exclusions, ignored/untracked runtime data preservation, recovery retention, expected-ref mutation, idempotency and per-target partial/lost-ack receipts. Semantic equivalence is not deletion authority. Cleanup failure cannot overwrite proven delivery.
Adds the EP owning design and scoped HY-E/HY-C/HY-Q roadmap, with a parent roadmap entry. No new first-canary/global-release prerequisite. All implementation remains PLANNED.
Documentation only: no provider/runtime code, API/schema migration, workflow, product version, grant, budget, installation or actual branch cleanup. Final exact-head hosted checks and separate Owner Authorization must be read before protected merge. Local validation is documentary DAG/schema/table review; no claim of local full EP tests or host qualification.