Fold hourly 0843 HIGH: hysteresis, instruct-tuning ECE, calibration does not compose - #35
Conversation
e60e6d9 to
6ab65a8
Compare
24601
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Adversarial review + testing gate — PASS on head 6ab65a8 (rebased onto main 35bec95 / #31+#32+#33).
Rebase / ID remap
Original head e60e6d9 was CONFLICTING because #31 already owns §113 / items 273–288 / batch #96. This branch was rebased onto latest main and remapped:
- notes §114 (0743 keeps §113)
- composition 289–302 (0743 keeps 273–288)
- findings #97 (0743 keeps #96)
- lock end
#23–#33; notes.md §114
#31 / #32 / #33 / #30 were not reopened or amended. README stays the shortened #33 map + one 0843 lock line (118 lines; not a wall restore).
Checklist
- No invented metrics / live REST drift — PASS. Census
A 273 · B 302 · C 372and ECE 0.113 left as theirs. 0843 pulse SemIf 2237★ kept; not mixed with #31’s 2241★. - Soft Noul never hard gate — PASS. Lock and cards keep
Soft Noul ≠ hard safety; ask-jev probabilities advisory; screening cutoff theater; 0.85 still soft elsewhere untouched. - No silent fallback / soundness theater — PASS. Hop-ECE called permutation-invariant with zero power on clustered trajectory failures; 25–60× headline withdrawn; hysteresis is policy attached to a probability (replay without inference).
- Name collisions / Qwen ≠ Archer / what-is-jev rename — PASS. Qwen2.5 / Qwen 3.8 / Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B ≠ Archer; Archer
promised_not_landed; Hub archerhume HTTP 401.g0runmezadam/what-is-jevIStunahansahin897/what-is-jev(id 1378007307), densify §109, not a second census. huncho ≠ gut/hunch siblings; jeval ≠ jevals; ask-jev ≠ mcp_jev; xiaohuaxi ≠ wjdjdakf17 ≠ baekenough. - Quotes theirs vs gloss — PASS. ECE 0.030/0.040 vs instruct 0.302/0.269, equal-width 0.113 vs quantile 0.076, BANKING77 BERT-Base 93.02 marked supervised-not-zero-shot, huncho
{enter:0.8, exit:0.6}quoted. - Section ID uniqueness vs merged #31 — PASS after remap.
## 114. Hourly 0843 HIGH; items 289–302 after 0743’s 288; Batch #97. - Diff docs/skill only; SKILL YAML parses; README scannable — PASS. Same 26-file hourly-fold surface (skill + research + CHANGELOG/README/CONTRIBUTING).
yaml.safe_loadof SKILL frontmatter OK (name: augustus). README 118 lines / 11471 bytes. - TESTING — local PASS:
python3 .agents/skills/augustus/scripts/evaluate_decisions.py --self-test→self-test ok(Brier, ranking≠calibration, equal-width≠quantile, hysteresis vs 0.7, hop-ECE invariance, cost-optimal threshold).python3 .agents/skills/augustus/scripts/uniqueness_gate.py→uniqueness-gate ok(2415-char lock × 21 overlays).- Pages gate strings present in
docs/index.md(TypeSafe Jev Choice/Score/Noul,Install the skill,LICENSE). GitHub Pages workflow not yet observed on this SHA; subscribe and do not merge on red.
Do not merge from this review. Head 6ab65a8. Final IDs: §114 / 289–302 / #97.
…ation does not compose Measurement/judgment fold off main after v0.4.0. Cards: huncho hysteresis, VladUZH Qwen2.5 ECE, sokudan JA encoder, what-is-jev rename densify, ask-jev advisory, jeval binning, deferred-crispification lemmas, screening cutoff, moss-jev recorded run, jev-benchmarks ranking≠calibration, usecases catalog, highlight BYO key, decision-circuits AND-product, xiaohuaxi constructed-case study. Qwen2.5 / Qwen 3.8 / Qwen3.8-27B ≠ Archer. Evaluator and uniqueness gate for the lock. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
The 0843 unreleased dump still said composition items 289–302 / batch #96 because a line-break hid the remap. This fold is batch #97; merged #31 keeps #96. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
6ab65a8 to
011667b
Compare
24601
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Adversarial review + testing gate — PASS on head 011667b (onto main 712223b = #34 Pages layout, which sits on #31+#32+#33).
Prior review was on 6ab65a8 before #34 landed. Rebase onto #34 was clean (README/ecosystem auto-merged; uniqueness lock still one substring).
IDs
- notes §114 (0743 keeps §113)
- composition 289–302 (0743 keeps 273–288)
- findings #97 (0743 keeps #96)
- lock end
#23–#33; notes.md §114
#31/#32/#33/#34/#30 not reopened or amended.
Checklist (FAIL blocks)
- No invented metrics / live REST drift — PASS. Census
A 273 · B 302 · C 372and ECE 0.113 left as theirs. 0843 SemIf 2237★ not mixed with #31’s 2241★. - Soft Noul never hard gate — PASS.
- No silent fallback / soundness theater — PASS. Hop-ECE permutation-invariant cannot audit clustered trajectory failures; 25–60× withdrawn; hysteresis is policy attached to a probability.
- Name collisions; Qwen ≠ Archer; what-is-jev rename honesty — PASS. Qwen2.5 / Qwen 3.8 / Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B ≠ Archer; Archer
promised_not_landed.g0runmezadam/what-is-jevIS tunahansahin897/what-is-jev (id 1378007307), not a second census. - Quotes theirs vs gloss — PASS.
- Section ID uniqueness vs merged #31 — PASS (§114 / 289+ / #97).
- Diff docs/skill/research fold surface; SKILL YAML parses; README scannable — PASS. 122 lines; #33/#34 map + one 0843 lock line; no wall restore.
- TESTING — local PASS:
evaluate_decisions.py --self-test→self-test okuniqueness_gate.py→uniqueness-gate ok(2415-char lock × 21 overlays + YAML)- Pages CI on previous SHA
6ab65a8was green (buildsuccess). Re-run on011667bafter #34 rebase; do not merge if that job is red.
Do not merge from this review.
|
Pages CI on head Local still green: PASS. IDs §114 / items 289–302 / batch #97. Mergeable clean. Not merging from this agent. |
Reconstruct PR #37 off latest main after merged #34/#35. Relock live REST 2264★ / zhihz 19★. Keep notes.md §117 / items 315–321 / batch #100; do not steal merged #35 §114 or reserved §115–§116. Extend uniqueness_gate for the 0922 consecutive lock. Docs/skill only. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
* Fold TianyuCodings/NanoJev unified-games-v1 densify Docs/skill only. notes.md §115 / composition 303–308 / findings #98. Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Do not reopen #31/#32/#33/#35. Reserve §114 for open #35 remap. Skip Archer. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Relock NanoJev live REST 1284★ (+1 vs fold 1283) Adversarial review head-check: GitHub TianyuCodings/NanoJev is 1284★. Keep uniqueness lock consecutive across 21 overlays. Quote docs/TYPESAFE_CONTRACT.md (README path), not the repo root 404. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Keep NanoJev densify on §115 after merged #35 Rebased onto main (0189825 / #35). Merged #35 owns notes §114 / items 289–302 / batch #97. This fold stays §115 / 303–308 / #98. Reorder composition-algebra so 289–302 precede 303–308. Drop open-#35 reservation language. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Relock NanoJev live REST 1288★ and Hub likes 58 Adversarial head-check after rebase: GitHub TianyuCodings/NanoJev is 1288★ (+4 vs 1284). Hub C-Tianyu/NanoJev likes 58 (+1 vs 57). Keep the 0915 uniqueness lock consecutive across 21 overlays. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Fix leftover Hub likes 57 next to 1288★ lock Adversarial review on 295e6e2: consecutive 0915 lock already has Hub likes 58, but validation.md prose still said 57. Live REST still 1288★ / likes 58. Do not mutate uniqueness_gate.py. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> * Relock NanoJev live REST 1289★ (+1 vs 1288) Adversarial head-check after leftover-likes fix: GitHub TianyuCodings/NanoJev is 1289★. Hub likes 58 held. Keep the 0915 uniqueness lock consecutive across 21 overlays. Do not mutate uniqueness_gate.py. Do not merge. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…, does not execute Docs/skill only off latest main after merged #34. IDs: notes.md §116 / items 309–316 / batch #99 (skip #36's §115 / 303–308 / #98 and #35 remap §114 / 289–302 / #97). Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…, does not execute Docs/skill only off latest main after merged #34. IDs: notes.md §116 / items 309–316 / batch #99 (skip #36's §115 / 303–308 / #98 and #35 remap §114 / 289–302 / #97). Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…, does not execute (#38) Docs/skill only off latest main after merged #34. IDs: notes.md §116 / items 309–316 / batch #99 (skip #36's §115 / 303–308 / #98 and #35 remap §114 / 289–302 / #97). Quote theirs; invented_signal false. Does not bump 0.4.0. Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…CE interleave Rebased onto latest main after merged #36/#38/#37/#40 (9824aa2). Do not reopen or amend #23–#40. Do not push onto open #41. Follow-up off main: ecosystem 0843 cited notes.md §113; README and CHANGELOG Unreleased still held dump walls; the 0843 lock ended at #33. Restore v0.4.0 scannability (dumps live in changelog-hourly). Extend the 0843 uniqueness lock through merged #34 and #35. Hop-ECE self-test covers reverse and even/odd interleave. uniqueness_gate checks Pages strings and refuses CHANGELOG/README dump walls. IDs unchanged: notes.md §114 / composition 289–302 / findings batch #97. Merged #31 still owns §113 / 273–288 / #96. Later folds keep §115–§118. Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
…CE interleave (#39) Rebased onto latest main after merged #36/#38/#37/#40 (9824aa2). Do not reopen or amend #23–#40. Do not push onto open #41. Follow-up off main: ecosystem 0843 cited notes.md §113; README and CHANGELOG Unreleased still held dump walls; the 0843 lock ended at #33. Restore v0.4.0 scannability (dumps live in changelog-hourly). Extend the 0843 uniqueness lock through merged #34 and #35. Hop-ECE self-test covers reverse and even/odd interleave. uniqueness_gate checks Pages strings and refuses CHANGELOG/README dump walls. IDs unchanged: notes.md §114 / composition 289–302 / findings batch #97. Merged #31 still owns §113 / 273–288 / #96. Later folds keep §115–§118. Co-authored-by: Cursor Agent <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Basit Mustafa <24601@users.noreply.github.com>
Hourly System One watch 0843 (Boise, ~2026-09-20T14:43Z). Rebased onto latest
mainafter merged #31 (0743), #32 (v0.4.0 /486e93e), #33 (README map), and #34 (Pages layout).IDs (remapped off merged #31)
research/notes.md§114 (0743 keeps §113)#23–#33; notes.md §114Do not reopen or amend PR #23–#34. Do not reply into the finished 0743 agent. Merged #31 owns §113 / 273–288 / #96 — leave it alone.
What landed
SKILL YAML/protocol/mapping index, mental-models Apply 0843, FAQ, fail table, validation, uniqueness lock across 21 overlays, CHANGELOG Unreleased (lock dump stays in
research/changelog-hourly.md). README stays the shortened #33/#34 map plus one 0843 lock line (122 lines; not a wall restore).HIGH cards (quote theirs; 0★ and size-0-WITH-CONTENTS still get real cards):
{enter:0.8, exit:0.6}hysteresis is policy, not a model property; replay policy without inference; providers ≠ productArcher still
promised_not_landed. Never treat Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B as Archer. Hubarcherhume/4rcherhumeHTTP 401 this pass. 0843 pulse snapshot kept (SemIf 2237★); not mixed with #31’s later 2241★.Mental-model spine (AI / SWE / business / life, not SWE-only): hysteresis is policy; ranking ≠ calibration; binning is a decision; hop-ECE is measurement theater as a trajectory audit; soft Noul ≠ hard safety.
Testing (Basit standing order)
Local: both green on
011667b. Self-test covers perfect Brier, ranking≠calibration (AUC=1, ECE>0.2), equal-width≠quantile on piled mass, hysteresis vs single 0.7, hop-ECE permutation invariance, cost-optimal threshold direction. Uniqueness gate requires the 0843 lock as one consecutive substring in 21 overlays + YAML-parse ofSKILL.md. Pages gate strings kept by #34 (TypeSafe Jev Choice/Score/Noul,Install the skill; LICENSE in the layout).Adversarial self-review: no wrappers/keys/install recipes; rename is IS not ≠; 25–60× withdrawn; BERT figures not zero-shot; screening 0.5 sensitivity does not transfer; independence for AND is assumed and recorded. Census
A 273 · B 302 · C 372and ECE 0.113 not remapped (not section IDs).Not merged from this agent. Review + CI before merge.